“…Compared with the other catalysts, Ni@NCNT-700 had the highestt otal Nc ontent,w hich suggested that the total Ncontent was not the key factor that influencedthe performanceofbifunctional oxygencatalysts,althoughe volution of the pyridinic-N content was related to performance.T his might be explained by pyridinic-N species providing the main active sites,w hich could reduce the adsorption energy of O 2 and improve the onset potential for the ORR,a sr eported previously. [16,20,22,[39][40][41][42] Figure 5d shows the Tafel plots of Co-, Fe-, and Ni-containing CNT catalysts towards the ORR.F e@NCNT-700 had ah igh onset potential (0.91 V) and poor half-wave potential in Figure 2c.Ahigh onset potential is usuallyr elated to sufficient pyridinic N, whereast he half-wave potential might be due to the worst Tafel slope (80.5 mV dec À1 ), representing poor kinetic processes,w hich was attributed to the absence of graphitic N. [8,12,40] Moreover, although Ni@NCNT-700 had the best Tafel slope (37.0 mV dec À1 ), which was attributedt ot he abundance of graphitic N, it still had the poorest ORR performance,w hich might be related to the presenceo fm etal-N species andconsequently the loss of pyridinic N. Herein, Co@NCNT-700, with suitable nitrogen chemical states (pyridinic and graphitic N), gave the best ORR performance.H owever, in the OER,N i@NCNT-700 displayed as imilar onset potential to that of Co@NCNT-700, which suggested that the metal element played an importantr ole in the OER process,r ather than the chemical state of N. Therefore,b oth nitrogen chemical state and metal element could significantly influence the electrochemical performanceo f these bifunctional oxygenc atalysts.T he clear change in the nitrogen chemical state of Ni@NCNT-700 helped us to clarify the confusion, to some extent, of why many kinds of Ni-containing nitrogen-doped carbon materials had huge differences in electrochemical processes in comparison with Co-/Fecontainingc atalysts,e specially for the ORR.O ur work is beneficial to the developmento fn itrogen-doped carbon materials as bifunctional ORR/OERc atalysts.…”