Developing understandings of clinical placement learning in three professions: Work that is critical to care

Abstract

professions: work that is critical to care. Alison Ledger and Sue KilminsterThis is the pre-peer reviewed version of the following article: Ledger A; Kilminster S. Developing understandings of clinical placement learning in three professions: work that is critical to care. Med Teach. 2015; 37 (4):360-365, which has been published in final form at http://informahealthcare.com/toc/mte/37/4 ABSTRACT Background This study contributes further evidence that healthcare students' learning is affected by underlying assumptions about knowledge, learning, and work.Aims To explore educators and students' understandings of early clinical placement learning in three professions (medicine, nursing, and audiology) and examine the profound impacts of these understandings on students' learning and healthcare work.Method Narrative interviews were undertaken with 40 medicine, nursing, and audiology students and 19 educators involved in teaching these student cohorts. Interview transcripts were read repeatedly and interpreted using current practice-based understandings of learning. 2Results Across interviews and professions, students and educators made distinctions between aspects of clinical placements which they understood as 'learning' and those which they tended to disregard as 'work'. In their descriptions of learning in clinical workplaces, medicine and nursing students and educators privileged activities considered to be technical or specialised, over activities that were understood to be more 'basic' to care. Furthermore, interviews with medical students and educators indicated that rich and unique possibilities for learning from other members of the healthcare team were missed. ConclusionsDistinctions between "learning" and "work" are unhelpful and all participation in clinical workplaces should be understood as valuable practice.Action is needed from all parties involved in clinical placement learning to develop understandings about learning in practice.

Novice students navigating the clinical environment in an early medical clerkship

“…The recent focus of many revision and renewal efforts on the medical curriculum overall and the pre‐clinical years in particular has neglected the clinical components of medical programmes except for efforts to understand and improve bedside teaching and clinical teaching, particularly at the bedside . Efforts to improve students' preparedness for practice in early clinical education have been particularly difficult and the provision of more time for students to be involved with patient care is not always feasible or affordable. More research into the ‘black box’ of student learning during the clinical phase of medical education is warranted, and this itself requires a focus on students' interactions with their learning environments…”

Transition processes through a longitudinal integrated clerkship: a qualitative study of medical students' experiences

“…Balmer and colleagues described undergraduate medical education as ‘a series of transitions between phases of the journey’ towards a career in medicine. Kilminster and colleagues recently characterised transitions as critically intensive learning periods, referring to physicians' transitions during clinical practice and medical students' initial exposure to clinical learning experiences. Teunissen and Westerman reported three key transitions throughout the medical education continuum, which comprise the transitions from non‐clinical to clinical training, from undergraduate to postgraduate medical education, and from postgraduate training to medical practice.…”

‘It benefits patient care’: The value of practice-based IPE in healthcare curriculums

“…For example, students may be able to develop competencies relating to professional roles and responsibilities from quali ed professionals. However, other competencies such as leadership and con ict management may be better suited to student collaboration, given the power and status differences between students and quali ed professionals [74]. A checklist for maximising practice-based IPE opportunities with a focus on utilising authentic and regularly occurring clinical activities has been developed in Australia [75].…”