“…Conversely, and as expected, addition of silver compounds such as AgOTs led to significantly lower ee due to competition from the racemic reaction catalysed by in situ generated strong acid (TsOH; entry 7). We next screened different combinations of various BINOL (1,1′-bi-2-naphthol)- and SPINOL (2,2′,3,3′-tetrahydro-1,1′-spirobi[indene]-7,7′-diol) CPAs4344454647 and Cu salts (entries 6 and 8–18) and found that the dual catalyst composed of CuBr (10 mol%) and ( S )- 1A (5 mol%) with 4-Ph-phenyl group at the 3,3′-positions was the best in terms of enantioselectivity (90% ee; entry 6). Among the solvents screened (entries 19–23), ethyl isobutyrate was found to be the most efficient one (98% yield and 99% ee; entry 23).…”