Development of social-moral reasoning among Kibbutz adolescents: A longitudinal cross-cultural study.

Abstract

The development of social-moral judgment among Israeli kibbutz adolescents was studied from the perspective of Kohlberg's theory of moral judgment development. The sample included 92 adolescents, 64 of whom were interviewed longitudinally over a two-to-nine year period. The study's purpose was to evaluate the validity of Kohlberg's model and measure in a cross-cultural context and to assess the cultural uniqueness of social-moral reasoning among kibbutzniks. The developmental findings strongly supported the validity of Kohlberg's structuraldevelopmental understanding of moral judgment. Stage change was found to be upward, gradual, and without significant regressions. Analyses also supported the internal consistency of the stages as operationally defined in the standardized scoring manual. There were no significant sex differences in moral development and fewer cultural differences than expected. Overall, the distribution of stage scores among the kibbutz subjects was unusually high when compared to the results of parallel studies in the United States and Turkey, the two previous longitudinal studies of moral judgment development that have used the standardized scoring system. The most important cultural variation involved the use of Stages 4/5 and 5. Whereas all of Kohlberg's stages were present among kibbutz members, not all elements of kibbutz postconventional reasoning were present in Kohlberg's model or scoring manual. In particular, the communal emphasis and collective moral principles of the kibbutz subjects were partially missed or misunderstood. This article presents the results of a longitudinal study of social-moral reasoning among Israeli adolescents. The research oh

Matching Traffic Safety Strategies to Youth Characteristics: A Literature Review of Cognitive Development

“…Findings from a variety of studies support the hierarchical and sequential nature of Kohlberg's stages (e.g., see Colby & Kohlberg, 1984;Colby et al, 1983;Edwards, 1985;Rest, 1979;Snarey, Reimer, & Kohlberg, 1985a;Turiel, 1973; Walker, deVries, & Bichard, 1984;Walker & Taylor, 1991). For example, results of a 20-year longitudinal study of Kohlberg's moral stage development reported by Colby et al (1983) indicated that subjects appeared to use a consistent logic or form of reasoning across a variety of moral dilemmas.…”

“…In particular, Gilligan (1977Gilligan ( ,1982 has argued that Kohlberg's moral stages have a built-in bias against females because they emphasize the acceptance of justice over the more traditional female values of caring and responsibility. However, Kohlberg's scoring system has been revised in recent years to avoid this problem (Hoffman, Paris, & Hall, 1994) and there is little evidence of sex differences in moral development (e.g., Colby, et al, 1983;Lapsley, 1996;Rest, 1979Rest, , 1993Silberman & Snarey, 1993;Snarey, Reimer, & Kohlberg, 1985a;Vasudev, 1988;Walker, 1984Walker, , 1989Walker, deVries, & Trevethan, 1987). Walker (1984), conducted one of the more thorough reviews of the literature and found that sex differences in moral reasoning are exceedingly rare.…”

Measuring the Ethical Levels of Special Education Teachers

“…It has been used in over 1,000 research studies, with "hundreds of thousands" of subjects from the late 1970s to the present and it has been used in 40 countries, with new studies taking place at the rate of approximately 150 per year [28]. A majority of moral reasoning theorists support that the construct of moral reasoning and stages of moral reasoning are cross-cultural as evidenced by the broad international use of the Defining Issues Test [43].…”

Adolescência, autonomia e pesquisa em seres humanos

“…É considerada uma teoria universalista. Assim sendo, acreditava que os seres humanos poderiam chegar a uma plena consciência moral, autônoma e independente da cultura do país ou do grupo social ao qual a pessoa pertencesse [14][15][16][17] . O autor argumentou que o desenvolvimento moral ocorreria em seis estágios, nos quais cada um teria suas próprias características e estaria na dependência da idade das pessoas.…”

“…Ademais, pelos mesmos motivos não se poderia transpor um estágio antes do outro 12,15 . Adolescência, autonomia e pesquisa em seres humanos Carol Gilligan 6 , ao estudar mais especificamente a psicologia do desenvolvimento da mulher, analisou e descreveu a formação da identidade feminina e a evolução do seu juízo moral, desde a adolescência até a idade adulta.…”