Development of the Bonding Representations Inventory To Identify Student Misconceptions about Covalent and Ionic Bonding Representations

Abstract

Teachers use multiple representations to communicate the concepts of bonding, including Lewis structures, formulas, space-filling models, and 3D manipulatives. As students learn to interpret these multiple representations, they may develop misconceptions that can create problems in further learning of chemistry. Interviews were conducted with 28 high school physical science, high school chemistry, and general chemistry students. The interviews focused on identifying student understanding of, and misconceptions about, covalent and ionic bonding representations through analysis of both student-created and expert-generated representations. Misconceptions about bonding representations were identified regarding four themes: (i) periodic trends, (ii) electrostatic interactions, (iii) the octet rule, and (iv) surface features. The Bonding Representations Inventory (BRI) was developed to quantify the prevalence of these misconceptions. The BRI was administered to 1072 high school chemistry, advanced placement chemistry, and general chemistry students across the United States. Content validity was determined through expert validation of the items, and concurrent validity was established by comparing the three groups of students. Reliability was determined through individual item analysis and through Ferguson's δ. Suggestions are offered for using the BRI in high school and general chemistry classrooms to inform the teaching of both bonding and representations.

Creating 3D physical models to probe student understanding of macromolecular structure

“…Common difficulties students face relate to problematic conceptions about the fundamental forces responsible for the formation and stabilization of these structures . Misconceptions about these forces develop at the general chemistry level and persist through biochemistry courses . To address these challenges, instructional materials need to be developed that target these areas in novel and engaging ways.…”

Assessment in Chemistry Education

“…The first chemistry concept inventory (the Chemistry Concepts Inventory) appeared in 2002 and covered a wide range of chemistry ideas . It has been followed by concept inventories focused on specific topics such as acidity, bonding, intermolecular forces, and solubility. Development of new CIs remains an active area of chemistry education research.…”

A Metodologia De Resolução De Problemas: Uma Experiência Para O Estudo Das Ligações Químicas

“…1,2,47 Alguns autores destacam a importância dos estudantes se apropriarem dos aspectos fundamentais das ligações, como as interações eletrostáticas, no caso da ligação iônica, para poderem complexificar tais conhecimentos quanto à força das ligações, às estruturas e propriedades dos distintos materiais analisados. 1,2,47 O Grupo B, na resolução do Problema 3, tomou por hipóteses que "O ponto de ebulição dos sais deve ser muito mais elevado que da água, porque virou um deserto de sal devido à evaporação da água" e que "Um experimento pode ser feito com água normal e água com bastante sal e ver o que ocorre". Na plenária, apresentaram os pontos de fusão dos sais que compõem o Salar e da água, assim como vídeos com experimentos que mostram as diferenças entre os pontos de fusão das substâncias em questão; também trouxeram uma tabela com as principais fontes de lítio, suas propriedades, como ocorre a solvatação e como isso afeta as propriedades químicas e imagens do Salar de Uyuni.…”