Diagnosing Students’ Learning Difficulties in the Eyes of Indonesian Mathematics Teachers

Abstract

Teachers’ diagnostic practice on students-difficulties is one of the important steps in designing and managing classroom lessons. The purpose of this study was to explore teachers’ perception and practices regarding diagnosing students’ learning difficulties. The participants of the study were 28 Indonesian mathematics teachers of Junior High School. The data was collected through a Focus Group Discussion and a teacher questionnaire. The data were analyzed qualitatively to describe how the teachers perceive learning difficulties and how the teachers diagnosed students’ learning difficulties. The results of the analysis reveal that the teachers do not yet perform an in-depth diagnosis of students’ difficulties in learning mathematics. The teachers only focus on the mathematics topics and non-mathematical issues, instead of on students’ thinking process. The teachers also do not differentiate the diagnosis, evaluation, and prediction test. With regard to the strategies used by the teachers to diagnose students’ difficulties, analyzing students’ responses to tests was the majority. In this respect, observing students’ learning process during classroom activities is rarely done by the teachers in the purpose of diagnosing students’ learning difficulties. The results of the diagnosis are mainly used as the basis for remedial and drill and practices. The results imply that more support is needed for teachers to improve their competences particularly in diagnosing students’ thinking process difficulties when learning mathematics.

The Effect of Treffinger Creative Learning Model with the Use RME Principles on Creative Thinking Skill and Mathematics Learning Outcome

“…In empowering students to be creative, the learning environment should be productive, engage in open-ended investigation and exploration, and accommodate students' cultural values (Palinussa, 2013). It was also found that an exhausting drill leads to the students' difficulty in learning mathematics (Wijaya, Retnawati, Setyaningrum, & Aoyama, 2019). To overcome the problem, teachers play the role of facilitators in class discussions and encourage them to participate by communicating and developing their ideas.…”

What the high school students say about mathematics homework

“…This problem may happen because their teachers do not yet perform an in-depth diagnosis of students' difficulties. (Wijaya et al, 2019). It may also happen because only a few teachers apply authentic judgment in the evaluation of learning, especially in mathematics (Sabri et al, 2019).…”

Mathematics Learning Through Character Education Based on Integrated Thematic Learning: A Development of Learning Materials

“…Various studies in implementing mathematics learning out state that schools' learning process has not paid attention to students' needs and potential for improving students' abilities (Wijaya et al, 2019). Learning tends to be theoretical, the role of the teacher is very dominant (teacher-centered), and the communication style is in one direction (Zain et al, 2012).…”