“…Additionally, the carbonado grains have a smooth, glossy surface that has been interpreted as "fusion crust" formed during a bolide impact (Shelkov et al 1997;Kletetschka et al 2000). The arguments for extraterrestrial origin have been weakened by recent observations published in the last several years: osbornite (TiN) has been shown to form in deep subduction environment (Dobrzhinetskaya et al 2007), deformation lamellae have been produced experimentally at mantle P-T conditions in carbonado diamond ), green and yellow CL colours have been encountered in terrestrial diamonds (De Stefano et al 2006), native metals have been described in kimberlite-hosted diamonds (Jacob et al 2004 and references therein), diamonds with very low carbon isotope compositions (down to -41‰ relative to V-PDB, Cartigny et al 2004;Cartigny 2007Cartigny , 2008De Stefano et al 2009), low aggregation states (Cartigny 2007(Cartigny , 2008Kagi and Fukura 2008) and elevated hydrogen contents (Hayman et al 2005) have been reported from various types of mantle-derived diamonds. The latter observation is important as the hydrogen content of the carbonado diamond can provide new means to investigate its origin.…”