Black soldier fly (BSF) melanin is a new supply of the brown-black pigment eumelanin. Given that eumelanin is a model bioelectronic material for applications such as medical devices and sensors, understanding BSF melanin’s electrical properties is important to confirm its viability as an advanced material. Presented here is a systematic, hydration dependent alternating current study of BSF melanin utilising both H2O and D2O vapours. There is a clear difference between the vapours, enabling a thorough analysis including Nyquist plots with model circuit analysis, broad band dielectric spectroscopic modelling as well as applying the Trukhan model to understanding free ion concentration and mobility changes as a function of hydration. We find that BSF melanin behaves similarly to previous reports on synthetic systems, and the analysis here shed additional light as to potential charge transport changes. Significantly, a key finding is that there are two different mobility mechanisms for ion transport depending on hydration