Digital Twin Concepts with Uncertainty for Nuclear Power Applications

Abstract

Digital Twins (DTs) are receiving considerable attention from multiple disciplines. Much of the literature at this time is dedicated to the conceptualization of digital twins, and associated enabling technologies and challenges. In this paper, we consider these propositions for the specific application of nuclear power. Our review finds that the current DT concepts are amenable to nuclear power systems, but benefit from some modifications and enhancements. Further, some areas of the existing modeling and simulation infrastructure around nuclear power systems are adaptable to DT development, while more recent efforts in advanced modeling and simulation are less suitable at this time. For nuclear power applications, DT development should rely first on mechanistic model-based methods to leverage the extensive experience and understanding of these systems. Model-free techniques can then be adopted to selectively, and correctively, augment limitations in the model-based approaches. Challenges to the realization of a DT are also discussed, with some being unique to nuclear engineering, however most are broader. A challenging aspect we discuss in detail for DTs is the incorporation of uncertainty quantification (UQ). Forward UQ enables the propagation of uncertainty from the digital representations to predict behavior of the physical asset. Similarly, inverse UQ allows for the incorporation of data from new measurements obtained from the physical asset back into the DT. Optimization under uncertainty facilitates decision support through the formal methods of optimal experimental design and design optimization that maximize information gain, or performance, of the physical asset in an uncertain environment.

Materials for Sustainable Nuclear Energy: A European Strategic Research and Innovation Agenda for All Reactor Generations

“…Their interpretation more and more often requires the help of artificial intelligence for pattern recognition [142]. This approach contributes crucially to a thorough plant lifecycle assessment and resonates and connects with the digitalization trend in the nuclear (and not only) industry, which also involves the development of digital twins for the key plant components [143]. These are virtual copies that, by combining in situ data collection with either physical or data-driven computer simulation techniques and models (see Section 3.2), allow the behaviour of the component in operation, or under off-normal conditions, to be anticipated, thereby optimizing its functioning, while enabling timely interventions and, if needed, replacements, whenever required [144].…”

Digital Twin for Integration of Design-Manufacturing-Maintenance: An Overview

“…The infrastructure, components and data flows required for the digital twin to enable Smart Assembly 4.0 are detailed and highlighted [95], [96] 2017 [118] 2022 Yongli Wei Shandong University…”

“…Intelligent operation and maintenance of industrial equipment is an important part of Industry 4.0 [158]. Intelligent operation and maintenance has been penetrated into various fields with the development of information technology, such as intelligent power station [159], intelligent network [160], engineering vehicles [161], green buildings group [162], micro-grid technology [163], communication network [164], nuclear power [118,[165][166][167][168], alleviation photovoltaic [169], bridge maintenance [170].…”

An efficient digital twin based on machine learning SVD autoencoder and generalised latent assimilation for nuclear reactor physics

“…The review article [51] focuses on uncertainty quantification (UQ) and software risk analysis of machine learning (ML) generated digital twin for the nearly autonomous management and control of nuclear power systems for prognostics and diagnostics supporting purposes. A more detailed discussion on digital twin concepts with uncertainty for nuclear power applications can be found in [47]. Additionally, the work [65] focuses on the development of technologies that enable digital-twinning efforts in nuclear proliferation detection.…”