In aqueous solution, biological decarboxylation
reactions proceed irreversibly to completion, whereas the reverse
carboxylation processes are typically powered by the hydrolysis of
ATP. The exchange of the carboxylate of ring-substituted arylacetates
with isotope-labeled CO2 in polar aprotic solvents reported
recently suggests a dramatic change in the partition of reaction pathways.
Yet, there is little experimental data pertinent to the kinetic barriers
for protonation and thermodynamic data on CO2 capture by
the carbanions of decarboxylation reactions. Employing a combined
quantum mechanical and molecular mechanical simulation approach, we
investigated the decarboxylation reactions of a series of organic
carboxylate compounds in aqueous and in dimethylformamide solutions,
revealing that the reverse carboxylation barriers in solution are
fully induced by solvent effects. A linear Bell–Evans–Polanyi
relationship was found between the rates of decarboxylation and the
Gibbs energies of reaction, indicating diminishing recombination barriers
in DMF. In contrast, protonation of the carbanions by the DMF solvent
has large free energy barriers, rendering the competing exchange of
isotope-labeled CO2 reversible in DMF. The finding of an
intricate interplay of carbanion stability and solute–solvent
interaction in decarboxylation and carboxylation could be useful to
designing novel materials for CO2 capture.