Discomfort and factual recollection in intensive care unit patients

Abstract

IntroductionA stay in the intensive care unit (ICU), although potentially life-saving, may cause considerable discomfort to patients. However, retrospective assessment of discomfort is difficult because recollection of stressful events may be impaired by sedation and severe illness during the ICU stay. This study addresses the following questions. What is the incidence of discomfort reported by patients recently discharged from an ICU? What were the sources of discomfort reported? What was the degree of factual recollection during patients' stay in the ICU? Finally, was discomfort reported more often in patients with good factual recollection?MethodsAll ICU patients older than 18 years who had needed prolonged (>24 hour) admission with tracheal intubation and mechanical ventilation were consecutively included. Within three days after discharge from the ICU, a structured, in-person interview was conducted with each individual patient. All patients were asked to complete a questionnaire consisting of 14 questions specifically concerning the environment of the ICU they had stayed in. Furthermore, they were asked whether they remembered any discomfort during their stay; if they did then they were asked to specify which sources of discomfort they could recall. A reference group of surgical ward patients, matched by sex and age to the ICU group, was studied to validate the questionnaire.ResultsA total of 125 patients discharged from the ICU were included in this study. Data for 123 ICU patients and 48 surgical ward patients were analyzed. The prevalence of recollection of any type of discomfort in the ICU patients was 54% (n = 66). These 66 patients were asked to identify the sources of discomfort, and presence of an endotracheal tube, hallucinations and medical activities were identified as such sources. The median (min–max) score for factual recollection in the ICU patients was 15 (0–28). The median (min–max) score for factual recollection in the reference group was 25 (19–28). Analysis revealed that discomfort was positively related to factual recollection (odds ratio 1.1; P < 0.001), especially discomfort caused by the presence of an endotracheal tube, medical activities and noise. Hallucinations were reported more often with increasing age. Pain as a source of discomfort was predominantly reported by younger patients.ConclusionAmong postdischarge ICU patients, 54% recalled discomfort. However, memory was often impaired: the median factual recollection score of ICU patients was significantly lower than that of matched control patients. The presence of an endotracheal tube, hallucinations and medical activities were most frequently reported as sources of discomfort. Patients with a higher factual recollection score were at greater risk for remembering the stressful presence of an endotracheal tube, medical activities and noise. Younger patients were more likely to report pain as a source of discomfort.

The Relationship of Discomforting Factors with Coping Strategies Among Patients in Cardiac Surgery Intensive Care Units

“…Findings showed that study participants greatly suffered from the effects of different discomforting factors. Two earlier studies also reported that ICU patients greatly suffered from the effects of physical and mental discomforting factors (8,27). However, two other studies showed that the level of ICU patients' discomfort was moderate (5, 28).…”

“…However, a study revealed that some patients considered cardiac surgery and CSICU hospitalization as the most significant life -threatening conditions in their lives (7). CSICU patients experience varying degrees of discomfort and stress induced by different external and internal factors (8). The most common discomforting factors in these units are healthcare providers, visitors, environmental factors, pain, anxiety, fear, loneliness, concerns, inability to verbally communicate due to endotracheal intubation, ringing telephones, equipment alarms, mechanical ventilation, staff's voices, heating and cooling systems, 24 -hour lighting, and unfamiliar routines (9)(10)(11).…”

Posttraumatic stress disorder among survivors of critical illness: creation of a conceptual model addressing identification, prevention, and management

“…Descriptions of patient memories reveal recollections of discomfort related to common elements of ICU care (42) and reports of pain, anxiety and fear are common (43). Frightening hallucinations and paranoid delusions that occur during a patient’s ICU stay, likely in the context of delirium, may continue to haunt individuals well after their critical illness has resolved (44).…”

Midazolam and propofol used alone or sequentially for long-term sedation in critically ill, mechanically ventilated patients: a prospective, randomized study

“…An ideal sedative should have a rapid onset, a short duration of action, a lack of accumulation, ease of titration and administration, and no cardiovascular and respiratory depression [1,2]. Until now, clinicians have been struggling to identify the ideal drug candidates to treat critically ill patients.…”