Does a child’s language ability affect the correspondence between parent and teacher ratings of ADHD symptoms?

Abstract

BackgroundRating scales are often used to identify children with potential Attention-Deficit/Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), yet there are frequently discrepancies between informants which may be moderated by child characteristics. The current study asked whether correspondence between parent and teacher ratings on the Strengths and Weakness of ADHD symptoms and Normal behaviour scale (SWAN) varied systematically with child language ability.MethodParent and teacher SWAN questionnaires were returned for 200 children (aged 61–81 months); 106 had low language ability (LL) and 94 had typically developing language (TL). After exploring informant correspondence (using Pearson correlation) and the discrepancy between raters, we report inter-class correlation coefficients, to assess inter-rater reliability, and Cohen’s kappa, to assess agreement regarding possible ADHD caseness.ResultsCorrelations between informant ratings on the SWAN were moderate. Children with LL were rated as having increased inattention and hyperactivity relative to children with TL; teachers, however, rated children with LL as having more inattention than parents. Inter-rater reliability of the SWAN was good and there were no systematic differences between the LL and TL groups. Case agreement between parent and teachers was fair; this varied by language group with poorer case agreement for children with LL.ConclusionChildren’s language abilities affect the discrepancy between informant ratings of ADHD symptomatology and the agreement between parents and teachers regarding potential ADHD caseness. The assessment of children’s core language ability would be a beneficial addition to the ADHD diagnostic process.Electronic supplementary materialThe online version of this article (doi:10.1186/s12888-017-1300-8) contains supplementary material, which is available to authorized users.

Contextual Factors Impact the Variability in ADHD Symptoms in Preschoolers with Situational Hyperactivity

“…The current study shows that there may be different contextual risks (but not necessarily unique factors) associated with clinical ADHD symptoms in preschoolers with SHA and HHA. Consistent with previous studies, teacher-reported ADHD symptoms were related to objective measurements, such as tests of inhibitory control (Jacobson et al, 2018), language ability (Gooch et al, 2017), and academic performance (Ho et al, 1996). Mannuzza et al (2002) showed in a 12-year follow-up study that children with pervasive ADHD and school-specific ADHD have a higher prevalence of antisocial disorder and greater difficulties with educational attainment and academic performance than children with home-specific ADHD.…”

Translation and cross-cultural adaptation of the Motor Behavior Checklist (MBC) into Brazilian Portuguese

“…Considering the school setting, most studies show that classroom teachers play a key role in providing information about a child's behavior. [2][3][4][5] Only a few studies have assessed instruments that rely on physical education teachers as a main source of information about emotional, behavioral, and/ or developmental problems in school-age children.…”

Does Inattention and Hyperactivity Moderate the Relation Between Speed of Processing and Language Skills?

“…Although it is possible to identify possible “cases” using SWAN algorithms, these should be treated with utmost caution. Indicative cases are reported in Supporting Information and discussed in detail elsewhere (Gooch, Maydew, Sears, & Norbury, ).…”