Does complementary resource use enhance ecosystem functioning? A model of light competition in plant communities

Abstract

Recent experiments on grassland ecosystems have shown that biodiversity can enhance ecosystem processes such as plant biomass production. Functional complementarity is generally regarded as the main class of mechanisms generating these effects of biodiversity on ecosystem functioning. Although intuitively appealing and supported by some data, the complementarity hypothesis has been little explored theoretically using mechanistic approaches. Here, we present a simple dynamical model for a light-limited terrestrial ecosystem to assess the effects of species diversity on light competition and total biomass in plant communities. Our model shows that competitive relaxation (reduction in average light competition intensity) due to differences in foliar architecture among species enhances total plant biomass in mixtures, but that competitive imbalance (generated by the variance of the average light competition intensity experienced by different species) can either reinforce the effect of competitive relaxation or counteract it and contribute to reducing total plant biomass. Thus, complementary resource use is not enough to increase total plant biomass in species-rich communities; competitive balance among species also plays an important role. We propose an operational measure of light-use complementarity using empirical field data on light absorption to test the presence of complementarity in natural plant communities.

Evidence of Microbial Regulation of Biogeochemical Cycles from a Study on Methane Flux and Land Use Change

“…Additionally, the focus of our study was CH 4 consumption, which is restricted to a selected group of microbial communities. Biodiversity offers a buffer (insurance hypothesis) to maintain an ecosystem process when environmental changes occur and is due to the functional redundancy of the organisms involved (54,55). Although this principle can be applied theoretically to any organisms (6), the situation for specific physiological groups of microbes, such as methanotrophs, is unusual because functional redundancy may not exist as such and because methanotrophy is a process limited to selected microbial taxa.…”

No evidence of spatial root system segregation and elevated fine root biomass in multi-species temperate broad-leaved forests

“…One explanation of this 'overyielding' phenomenon is complementary use of light, water or nutrients by the component species (Loreau 1998;Hooper et al 2005;Cardinale et al 2007;Yachi and Loreau 2007). Such complementarity effects have been not only described for grassland systems (e.g.…”

Loss of functionally unique species may gradually undermine ecosystems

“…[1,2]) towards understanding the mechanisms through which this process occurs (e.g. [3]). Species richness indices implicitly assume that all species contribute equally to ecosystem functioning and stability.…”