Domesticating the “Smarter Than You” Home. Gendered Agency Scripts Embedded in Smart Home Discourses

Abstract

Smart home networked systems promise a mode of comfort, efficiency and convenience that infers the easing of housekeeping chores. They impact on the moral economy of the home in ways we barely understand. Drawing on feminist technology studies and domestication theory, this article investigates how gendered relations are assigned and legitimated in smart home marketing reports and advertisements to enquire whether men and women are invited to participate equally or unequally in smart home technology. This raises questions about how promotional texts might influence and circumscribe domestic adoption. An interpretive content analysis of marketing reports and advertisements explains the pedagogic role of smart scenarios in coaxing and coaching householders to domesticate IoT-operated technology. The concept of “agency script” is employed to explain how smart actions are conveyed and assigned by promotional texts to activate smart home adoption. This enables an enquiry into the values and ideals conveyed in smart home discourses at the commodification stage of domestication and their implications for later stages. We might assume that smart technology democratises the home by fostering gender equality in the organisation of homemaking routines. But a critical study of the narrativization and assignment of smart home agency reveals significant gender disparities.

Who cares about digital disconnection? Exploring commodified digital disconnection discourse through a relational lens

“…Adding to the above assemblage are processes of commodification in which fields, things, and social relations are attributed monetary value and integrated into a market economy (Harvey, 2005). Marketing plays a significant role in commodification: By representing commodities in certain ways towards targeted consumers, it shapes their (perceived) purposes and meanings in daily life (Chambers, 2020;Silverstone, 2006). Care work has not been spared from commodification and other market logics, with non-waged forms of care having been privatized and outsourced into waged labor (Bakker, 2007;Harvey, 2005;Schwiter and Steiner, 2020).…”

Commodification of women in Sido Muncul advertisement Sido Susu Ginger drink Ariel Tatum version

“…This has been explained by economic observer figures; according to Wirawan, (2017) the trade also affects the use of the body and body representation (body sign) as commodities in various cultural forms of capitalism, raising various issues that not only concern economic relations but especially the economic role of women in them. In the end, women become commodities (Chambers, 2020). This is what is called the commodification of women (Lal, 2023) .…”