Dropout, Autonomy and Reintegration in Spain: A Study of the Life of Young Women on Temporary Release

Abstract

This study analyses the psycho-educational and social paths of women prisoners after the time they drop out of school as minors, based on different variables related to autonomy and their preparedness to face temporary release. Methods: Qualitative and quantitative methods were used to analyse a national sample of 310 women prisoners (30.1% of the population) in 31 prisons through a mixedmode questionnaire and interview. We analysed the significant association of variables related to dropout and obtained a log-linear model that relates dropout to recidivism and Roma culture. Work experience was analysed using the McNemar test, and variables influencing the participant's job at the time of the study were analysed by applying cluster analysis. Results: Young women comprise 66.6% of individuals who drop of the education system as minors (primary 49.3% and secondary 22%). They drop out between the ages of 7 and 17, and have traits of greater vulnerability than those who stayed in school until adulthood. In this population, we find a significant association with various factors: belonging to Roma culture, having family members in prison and delinquent recidivism; and higher unemployment (43.4%) and low income before entering prison. This situation is increasing today. In prison, these women had more connection to education/training, which can improve their employability. They also encounter difficulties with personal security, decision-making, personal/professional dependence, planning for the future, administrative matters and handling information and communication technologies, jobseeking skills, etc. Their self-perceived strengths are, however, assuming responsibility, taking orders, respecting schedules and timetables, working on a team and feeling prepared to start a job, as well as having optimistic convictions about the future. Conclusion: The vulnerabilities and risk factors studied have a negative influence primarily on processes of personal, social and job autonomy in female minors who

Social reintegration programs for former inmates in Brazil: is there a gender perspective?

“…Providing these women with adequate opportunities for professional training during incarceration can help them get a job after serving their sentence, thus facilitating social reintegration and breaking the cycle of social vulnerability and violence. Managers must know that the training and the possibility of employment can correspond to market demands and aim to increase these women's actual chances of earning a decent wage after imprisonment 3,15,16 .…”

“…The Brazilian Penitentiary System, in general, does not prioritize a policy with a gender approach due to its various deficiencies, which causes gaps in the social reintegration of women deprived of their liberty. The gender approach is vital so that the particularities of women can be considered in the social reintegration measures offered by governmental and non-governmental institutions [14][15][16] .…”

Factors of Prison Recidivism in Women: A Socioeducational and Sustainable Development Analysis

“…Along these lines, other studies have shown that women inmates typically have low or medium-level education and follow cultural and educational paths with many disadvantages before going to prison [1,57], with 30% of women inmates in prison regimes having no education and 40% of women having only completed primary school [58]. Similarly, 66.6% of the young women left the education system as minors (primary 49.3% and secondary 22%), becoming more vulnerable than those who stayed in school to adult age [59].…”

“…As to the relationship between formal education and attending training courses, Añaños et al [59] show that training in prison can become an opportunity to increase prosocial attitudes, improve emotional wellbeing, and decrease the risk of unemployment. These opportunities become the starting point for preparing for life in freedom.…”

The Professional Dimension in Spanish Prison Socio-Educational Action

“…On the other hand, the period of incarceration in an ordinary regime is considered a conditioning factor by the majority of open regime professionals with positive convictions in the reintegration process (94.3%), who consider that incarceration in penal units is a mechanism of social vulnerability and exclusion that hinders reintegration [3,10,17,36]. In response, the Prison Institution introduces the open regime (3rd degree and 2nd degree art.…”