Small fiber neuropathy (SFN) is a relatively common, but largely understudied neurological syndrome which has affected the lives of many globally. The common symptoms of SFN include pain, dysesthesia, and autonomic dysfunction, which are caused by damage to small nerve fibers. Due to its heterogeneous nature, SFN causes a multitude of symptoms which makes the disease and its subtypes difficult to diagnose. Furthermore, as the pathophysiology of SFN remains largely enigmatic, no cause is found in around 50% of the cases and these are classified as idiopathic SFN (iSFN). The difficult task of diagnosing SFN, and the even more elusive feat of hunting for the underlying etiology, demands accurate, precise, preferably noninvasive, and affordable tools, or a combination of them. Accordingly, appropriate biomarkers for SFN are needed to stratify patients and develop cause-centered treatments in addition to symptomatic treatments. As peripheral axons grow and repair, identifying underlying causes of SFN and intervening early may spur axonal regeneration in young patients, which can greatly improve their symptoms and improve quality of life. This narrative review aims to objectively highlight functional, histological, and molecular biomarkers to aid clinicians in discerning the diagnostic tests they should use to diagnose, confirm and determine the etiology of SFN. The strengths and limitations of each potential biomarker will be discussed. Clearer diagnostic criteria, guidelines, and work-up for SFN are required for clinicians to better identify the disease in patients presenting with non-specific symptoms.