Every method of deformational nanostructuring is characterized by typical scheme of the processing. One of the main aspects of such methods is the behavior of the processed metal on the contact surface with a tool. The aim of this study is to analyze the distribution of deformation from the contact surface of the workpiece to the bulk in different methods of deformational nanostructuring. High carbon steel was chosen for the analysis. Simulation was performed in ABAQUS software. Methods based on different kinds of deformation were chosen for the comparison: method based on simple shear in one deformation zone, method based on simple shear with torsion, method based on simple shear in two deformation zones with torsion, and continuous method of combined deformational processing by drawing with torsion. Data of the distribution of principle strains, tangential strains, equivalent strains, and the von-Mises equivalent stress from the contact surface to the depth of 0.05 mm to the bulk were obtained. The results of simulation can be used for prediction of steel behavior under different kinds of deformational processing.