A hybrid mathematical modeling/optimization approach based on the response surface methodology (RSM) and desirability function (DF) capabilities was applied here to imitate and optimize the mechanical properties of thermoplastic starch‐based biocomposites. In order to prepare the biodegradable and renewable biocomposites, rice straw (RS) was chemically modified to obtain more effective sustainable reinforcing fillers for starch, having semi‐thermoset and core‐shell structures. A combination of different RS products was used in the biocomposites and the composition of RS‐based fillers was chosen as control variable. A series of experiments, by using RSM, were designed to assess the effects of filler loading and composition on the Young modulus, tensile strength, ultimate strain, and absorbed energy of the biocomposites. The best‐fitting regression functions were identified via RSM statistical analysis and transformed into DF to optimize the desired responses concurrently. The findings demonstrate that the starch/RS product biocomposites with optimum elastic modulus (339.3 MPa), tensile strength (9.8 MPa), elongation at break (13.8%), and absorbed energy (1831.2 kJ/m2) were obtained by incorporating RS‐based fillers with both semi‐thermoset and core‐shell structures in combination with each other at loadings of 13.5 and 6.5 phr, respectively.