Effect of Verbal Empathy and Touch on Anxiety Relief in Patients Undergoing Flexible Bronchoscopy: Can Empathy Reduce Patients' Anxiety?

Abstract

Background: Patients undergoing flexible bronchoscopy usually experience anxiety before and during the procedure. Objectives: We performed this study to investigate whether verbal empathy and intentional touch from a bronchoscopist could reduce anxiety in patients undergoing flexible bronchoscopy. Methods: We conducted a prospective randomized trial in a university-affiliated hospital. Participants were randomly assigned to one of the following groups: a control group, a verbal empathy group, or a verbal empathy and touch group. The staff pulmonologist performing bronchoscopy expressed verbal empathy and used touch by speaking to the patient (using predefined short statements) and making eye contact, and by laying his/her left hand on the patient's right shoulder. We assessed the level of patient anxiety with a visual analog scale before and after the intervention. Results: Participants were 267 patients with a median age of 65 years; 62.2% were men. Although there were no differences in changes in anxiety between the three groups, subgroup analysis of the visual analog scale including participants with higher baseline anxiety (empathy and touch group participants with anxiety ≥60 mm; empathy group and empathy and touch group participants with anxiety ≥70 mm) showed a larger reduction in anxiety than the control group. Conclusions: Verbal empathy and touch given by a bronchoscopist before bronchoscopy reduced anxiety in patients with high baseline anxiety levels.

Effects of doctors’ empathy abilities on the cellular immunity of patients with advanced prostate cancer treated by orchiectomy: the mediating role of patients’ stigma, self-efficacy, and anxiety

“…For example, Flickinger et al 22 found that the empathy of doctors affected the self-efficacy of AIDS patients. Choi et al 23 confirmed that the more that doctors who performed bronchoscopy were able to empathize with their patients, the less anxiety the patients felt. The finding that doctors’ empathy affects patients’ psychology may be explained by the following reasons: 1) doctors with strong empathy can better understand the patients’ stigma and provide more compassionate care than less empathic doctors, which helps to relieve the patients’ negative emotions, such as stigma.…”

Influence of oncology nurses’ empathy on lung cancer patients’ cellular immunity

“…We found close associations between nurses’ empathy and lung cancer patients’ cellular immunity. Previous studies found that medical staff/clinican’s empathy was related to patient’s outcomes, including increasing satisfaction and psychological well-being, 24 reducing patients’ anxiety before a bronchoscopy, 25 reducing distress, 26 and improving self-efficacy of patients with HIV. 27 Empathy also has an impact on the patients’ physiological parameters.…”

Humanistic medicine in anaesthesiology: development and assessment of a curriculum in humanism for postgraduate anaesthesiology trainees

“…This is crucial, as surgery can be a uniquely stressful life event and anaesthesiologists play a key role in determining patients' perioperative experience. There is a growing body of literature that shows that empathetic care improves patient outcomes by reducing anxiety, 34,35 improving communication, 36 and thereby improving patient care. 36e38 Our work further supports this notion by showing improvement in self-reported humanistic skills, patient-perceived humanistic skills, and patientreported pain and anxiety scores after the intervention (Kirkpatrick Levels 2e4).…”