Effectiveness, Safety and Cost-Effectiveness of Homeopathy in General Practice – Summarized Health Technology Assessment

Abstract

Introduction: The Health Technology Assessment report on effectiveness, cost-effectiveness and appropriateness of homeopathy was compiled on behalf of the Swiss Federal Office for Public Health (BAG) within the framework of the ‘Program of Evaluation of Complementary Medicine (PEK)’. Materials and Methods: Databases accessible by Internet were systematically searched, complemented by manual search and contacts with experts, and evaluated according to internal and external validity criteria. Results: Many high-quality investigations of pre-clinical basic research proved homeopathic high-potencies inducing regulative and specific changes in cells or living organisms. 20 of 22 systematic reviews detected at least a trend in favor of homeopathy. In our estimation 5 studies yielded results indicating clear evidence for homeopathic therapy. The evaluation of 29 studies in the domain ‘Upper Respiratory Tract Infections/Allergic Reactions’ showed a positive overall result in favor of homeopathy. 6 out of 7 controlled studies were at least equivalent to conventional medical interventions. 8 out of 16 placebocontrolled studies were significant in favor of homeopathy. Swiss regulations grant a high degree of safety due to product and training requirements for homeopathic physicians. Applied properly, classical homeopathy has few side-effects and the use of high-potencies is free of toxic effects. A general health-economic statement about homeopathy cannot be made from the available data. Conclusion: Taking internal and external validity criteria into account, effectiveness of homeopathy can be supported by clinical evidence and professional and adequate application be regarded as safe. Reliable statements of cost-effectiveness are not available at the moment. External and model validity will have to be taken more strongly into consideration in future studies.

Medicinal Systems of Complementary and Alternative Medicine: A Cross-Sectional Survey at a Pediatric Emergency Department

“…16 The use of CAM in Switzerland, its efficacy, appropriateness, and cost-effectiveness have been evaluated within the frames of a federal program (Complementary Medicine Evaluation Program, PEK), which revealed that CAM was associated with a higher patient satisfaction, weaker=less frequent side-effects, and lower costs than conventional medicine (CM). 15,[17][18][19][20] The use of CAM by children in Switzerland has just started to be unveiled. A previous study performed at the intensive care unit of the Children's Hospital of Zurich revealed that 18% of the parents of critically ill pediatric patients applied some form of CAM.…”

Homeopathic Treatment of Infertility: A Medical and Bioethical Perspective

“…However, several studies present data that homeopathic remedies are not operating though a placebo response. Several reports, for example, show that homeopathic remedies are effective in treating infants, comatose patients and animals [7][8][9][10][11][12][13] induce oestrus in cows [14]. Another report has shown that homeopathic remedies might be trigger cytolytic activity in breast cancer cells maintained in culture [15].…”

Methodological Implications of Nonlinear Dynamical Systems Models for Whole Systems of Complementary and Alternative Medicine

“…External validity, on the other hand, addresses the generalizability of anobservedeffectforthelargerpopulationfromwhomthe study participants were drawn; and model validity relates to the concordance between the study design and an idealized setting(formoredetails,see [1,5]). Forexternalandmodel validity in studies, WS-CAM practitioners would need to (a)useindivisible,interdependent,iterativepackagesofcare rather than isolated standardized elements of a package; (b) ensure that practitioners involved in studies are well trained and highly experienced; (c) treat real-world patients withconfoundingco-morbidconditions,psychosocialfactors, and other treatments; and (d) evaluate complex, emergent patient-wide outcomes in each case, rather than the simple organ-ordisease-specificeffects.ThemajorfeaturesofWSCAMincludecoordinated,adaptive,andindivisiblepackages ofcareandemergentpositivepatient-wideoutcomesinboth globalfunction(e.g.,qualityoflife)andmultiplelocalsubsystems(e.g.,'non-specific'changesinmanysymptoms,notjust the original chief complaint).…”