Effects of different exercise intensity on bone mineral density in adults: a comparative systematic review and meta-analysis

Abstract

Purpose The primary objective of the present systematic review and meta-analysis was to determine the effect of differing exercise intensity on (areal) bone mineral density (BMD) at lumbar spine and hip in adults by a comparative meta-analysis. Methods A systematic review of the literature according to the PRISMA statement included: (a) exercise trials, (b) with ≥two study arms that compared different exercise intensities, (c) intervention ≥6 months, (d) BMD assessments at lumbar spine (LS) or hip. Five electronic databases were scanned without language restrictions up to July 2021. The present analysis of exercise intensity was conducted as a mixed-effect meta-analysis and applied "type of exercise" and "study duration" as moderator in subgroup analyses. Outcome measures were standardized mean differences (SMD) for BMD changes at the LS, and hip. Results Eleven exercise studies with 26 study arms were included. Although the effect of high-intensity exercise was more pronounced on LS-BMD (SMD: 0.19, 95%-CI: 0.61 to -0.23) and hip-ROI (0.17, 0.38 to -0.04), we did not observe significant differences between the groups (LS-BMD: p=0.373 and hip-BMD: p=0.109). We observed a substantial level of heterogeneity between the trials for LS-but not for hip-BMD. Applying "type of exercise" and "study duration" as moderators did not significantly modify the differences between low and high exercise intensity on BMD at LS or hip. Conclusion There is insufficient evidence for a superior effect of high-intensity exercise on areal BMD at lumbar spine and hip in people aged 50 years and older. Varying exercise intensity with periods of lower exercise intensity intermitted by higher intensity might be a promising option to address the issue of exercise intensities in intervention studies. KeywordsBMD • Exercise • Intensity • Type of exercise • Meta-analysis * W.

Exercise training and bone mineral density in postmenopausal women: an updated systematic review and meta-analysis of intervention studies with emphasis on potential moderators

“…One solution to this problem might be comparative meta-analyses that include trials with two study arms with diverging exercise parameters (e.g. intensity [ 122 ] or training frequency [ 119 ]) but otherwise identical protocols (… and participants).…”

Impact of Physical Rehabilitation on Bone Biomarkers in Non-Metastatic Breast Cancer Women: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

“…On the other hand, several controversies are still open about the macroscopical effects of physical exercise on BMD, and previous systematic reviews and meta-analyses reported insufficient evidence to support a superior effect of one specific exercise modality [ 67 , 68 ]. However, it should be noted that the currently available literature focused on standardized exercise programs without focusing on the biological effects of physical exercise in an individualized rehabilitation plan.…”

Additive Effects of Exercise and Vitamin D Supplementation (with and without Calcium) on Bone Mineral Density in Older Adults: A Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis

“…One may argue that this approach might not identify all eligible reports or studies. However, one should bear in mind that this study was conducted within the framework of the (German) National guideline of fracture prevention that is based on several systematic reviews and meta-analyses in the area of exercise and BMD (e.g., [ 4 , 11 , 12 , 42 ]). Using synergy effects between the searches and considering the close interaction between the researchers, we are very confident that all eligible studies have been included in the present work.…”