Effects of Nonaxisymmetric Tip Clearance on Axial Compressor Performance and Stability

Abstract

The effects of circumferentially non-uniform tip clearance on axial compressor performance and stability have been investigated experimentally and analytically. A theoretical model for compressor behavior with non-axisymmetric tip clearance has been developed and used to design a series of first-of-a-kind experiments on a four-stage, low speed compressor. The experiments and computational results together show clearly the central physical features and controlling parameters of compressor response to non-axisymmetric tip clearance.It was found that the loss in stall margin was more severe than that estimated based on average clearance. The stall point was, in fact, closer to that obtained with uniform clearance at the maximum clearance level. The circumferential length scale of the tip clearance (and accompanying flow asymmetry) was an important factor in determining the stall margin reduction. For the same average clearance, the loss in peak pressure rise was 50% higher for an asymmetry with fundamental wavelength equal to the compressor circumference than with wavelength equal to one-half the circumference. The clearance asymmetry had much less of an effect on peak efficiency; the measured maximum efficiency decrease obtained was less than 0.4 percent compared to the 8% decrease in peak pressure rise due to the asymmetric clearance. The efficiency penalty due to non-axisymmetric tip clearance was thus close to that obtained with a uniform clearance at the circumferentially-averaged level.The theoretical model accurately captured the decreases in both steady-state pressure rise and stable operating range which are associated with clearance asymmetry. It also gave a good 1 Permanent address: California Institute of Technology, Pasadena, California. Idescription of the observed trends of (i) increasing velocity asymmetry with decreasing compressor flow, and (ii) decreasing effect of clearance asymmetry with decreasing dominant wavelength of the clearance distribution. The time resolved data showed that the spatial structure of the pre-stall propagating disturbances in the compressor annulus was well represented and that the stability limiting process could be linked to the unsteady structure of these disturbance modes.The model was also utilized for parametric studies to define how compressor performance and stability is affected by the circumferential distribution of clearance, steady-state compressor pressure-rise characteristic, and system dynamic parameters. Sensitivity to clearance asymmetry was found to fall off strongly with the (asymmetry-related) reduced frequency and to increase with peak pressure rise and increasing curvature of the characteristic near the peak.2

Degradation of gas turbine performance in natural gas service

“…Changes in surface quality and airfoil geometry reduce efficiency and work capability of the stage. Increased clearances reduce surge margin, reduce the efficiency, cause a reduction in stage work, and reduce the compressor flow capacity (Kurz and Brun, 2001;Spakovszky et al, 1999;Graf et al, 1998;Smith and Cumpsty, 1984;Frith, 1992).…”

Uncertainty propagation in a reduced order thermo-acoustic model

“…where we have applied (9) and the assumption that u r = 0 on the interior. Equations (7) and (8) can be simplified to…”

“…Optimal mistuning in arrays of bladed disks has appeared in [18], [20]. A study of the effects of asymmetry on compressor stall inception has appeared in [9].…”

Rotordynamic Effects of Compressor Rotor-Tip Clearance Asymmetry

“…Ehrich 11 used the parallel compressor model and data from the General Electric Low Speed Research Compressor to predict mostly backward whirling forces. Recently, Graf et al 12 developed a model to predict the effects of clearance asymmetry on compressor stability.…”