“…The following proposals are urgently to be motivated: (1) RHE should be used as RE as far as possible, and if other REs are adopted, their details of potential conversion vs. RHE should be illustrated, and there is no need to conduct iR-drop correction if Luggin capillary is placed correctly in TF-RDE test; (2) To simulate the standard MEA polarization protocol proposed by DOE and narrow the gap of ORR activities obtained via TF-RDE and MEA, reciprocating LSV/SCV should be performed to characterize the ORR performances of PGMs; (3) Connotations like M A and S A should be defined precisely, and K-L equation as well as the selection of j L should be emphasized; (4) The details of calculation processes, such as m Pt , j A , j L , and ECSA et al., should be listed in article or supplemental information for the better readability for readers. Furthermore, considering the limited mass transport in TF-RDE and its discrepancy in test conditions with respect to MEA, whose fabrication process is very much an art, floating electrode ( Lin et al., 2020 ; Zalitis et al., 2013 ) and gas diffusion electrode ( Inaba et al., 2018 ; Mardle et al., 2020 ; Roudbari et al., 2020 ) techniques have been proposed in recent years and are under rapid development to bridge the activity gap between TF-RDE and MEA while maintaining its simplicity, convenience, and controllability.…”