Binge-watching is an increasingly popular way to consume media whose impact on users has been shown to be, at times, both positive and negative. Aiming to reconcile the discrepancies of prior research with a more holistic approach, the present study assesses the potential impact of binge-watching while taking into account both the viewer’s motivational antecedents (i.e., coping/escapism, emotional enhancement) and individual differences (i.e., transportability, self-control, sensation seeking). In a sample of 251 participants, these variables and their myriad pathways were analyzed through structural equation modeling and mediation analysis. Results show that binge-watching’s relationship with viewer well-being is contingent upon a complex array of associations between individual and motivational differences and the nature of one’s engagement in the activity. Theoretical and practical implications of these findings are discussed, as well as the limitations of the study and their ability to inform future research on binge-watching.