Some robots have been given emotional expressions in an attempt to improve human-computer interaction. In this article we analyze what it would mean for a robot to have emotion, distinguishing emotional expression for communication from emotion as a mechanism for the organization of behavior. Research on the neurobiology of emotion yields a deepening understanding of interacting brain structures and neural mechanisms rooted in neuromodulation that underlie emotions in humans and other animals. However, the chemical basis of animal function differs greatly from the mechanics and computations of current machines. We therefore abstract from biology a functional characterization of emotion that does not depend on physical substrate or evolutionary history, and is broad enough to encompass the possible emotions of robots.Interest in the creation of robots with emotions is fourfold. First, current technology already shows the value of providing robots with 'emotional' expressions (e.g. computer tutors) and bodily postures (e.g. robot pets) to facilitate human-computer interaction. Second, this raises the question of the possible value (or inevitability) of future robots not only simulating emotional expression but actually 'having emotions'. Third, this in turn requires us to re-examine the neurobiology of emotion to generalize concepts first developed for humans and then extended to animals so that the question of robot emotions becomes meaningful. And fourth, this suggests in turn that building 'emotional robots' could also provide a novel test-bed for theories of biological emotion.This article samples the state of the art on current robot technology, and examines recent work on the neurobiology of emotions, to ground our suggestions for a scientific framework in which to approach robot 'emotions'. The question of 'emotional robots' being used to test theories of biological emotion is of great interest, but beyond the scope of this article.
Different kinds of emotionsThere is a wide spectrum of feelings, from the 'motivation' afforded by drives such as the search for food afforded by hunger [1] to 'emotions' in which, at least in humans, cognitive awareness might be linked to feeling the 'heat' of love, sorrow or anger, and so on. But as we have no criterion for saying that a robot has 'feelings', we will seek here to understand emotions in their functional context, noting that not all emotions need be like human emotions. We analyze emotion in two main senses:(1) Emotional expression for communication and social coordination.(2) Emotion for organization of behavior (action selection, attention and learning).The first concerns 'external' aspect of emotions; the second 'internal' aspects. In animals, these aspects have co-evolved. How might they enter robot design? Both robots and animals need to survive and perform efficiently within their 'ecological niche' and, in each case, patterns of coordination will greatly influence the suite of relevant emotions (if such are indeed needed) and the means whereby they are co...