Emotion recognition and extraversion of medical students interact to predict their empathic communication perceived by simulated patients

Abstract

BackgroundThis study assessed the impact of medical students’ emotion recognition ability and extraversion on their empathic communication, as perceived by simulated patients in a training context.MethodsThis study used a crossed-effect data structure and examined 245 students in their fourth year of medical school. The students’ personality traits were assessed based on a self-assessment questionnaire of the short form of the Big Five Inventory; their emotion recognition ability was measured using a performance test (Diagnostic Analysis of Nonverbal Accuracy-2, Adult Facial Expressions). Simulated patients evaluated the medical students’ empathic communication.ResultsStudents with a combination of high emotion recognition ability and extraversion received more positive ratings from simulated patients than their fellow students with a combination of emotion recognition ability and low extraversion. The main effects of emotion recognition or extraversion were not sufficient to yield similar effects. There were no other effects related to the remaining Big Five variables.ConclusionsThe results support the hypothesis that to build rapport with patients, medical staff need to combine emotional capabilities with a dispositional interest in interpersonal encounters.

Personality characteristics of empathy profiles – practical implications for education of medicine students

“…Extravert people, who are more focused on external world rather than emotions, and who seek contact with others [ 10 ] – are less susceptible to personal distress, as they are less concentrated on their “self”. In a study on communication between a general practitioner and a simulated patient, Extraversion and Emotion Recognition Ability, turned to be the most important factors that influenced positive assessment of the relation by patients [ 15 ]. The dimension of Openness and its subcomponents are in a positive correlation with Empathetic Concern and Perspective Taking [ 11 , 13 ].…”

Cultural influences and the Objective Structured Clinical Examination

“…Students speak with standardized patients in carefully structured, but dynamic interactions. Importantly, relational influences between standardized patient and students are operational, [1][2][3] influencing student 1,3 and standardized patient performance. Neither the impact of participants' cultural backgrounds or attitudes nor their methods for overcoming their own unconscious biases are well-characterized.…”

The Relationship of Pre-Clerkship Immature Defense Style in Medical Students with Physician-Patient Interactions

“…Extraversion and agreeableness are also important for interpersonal relationships (Abbiati et al 2016) and appear crucial for effective physician-patient interactions (PPIs). Schreckenbach et al (2018) found that extraversion together with high emotion recognition, but not extraversion alone, predicted positive PPIs of medical students with standardized patients (SPs). Another study showed that medical students' empathic ability was not associated with any particular personality traits (Seitz et al 2018).…”