Empathy and psychopathic traits as predictors of selection into business or psychology disciplines

Abstract

Objective: The attraction, selection, and attrition model posits that individuals actively self-select into vocational and educational environments based on their personality traits and values. The present study investigated whether pre-existing empathy and psychopathic personality trait differences in newly enrolled first year undergraduate students predicted selection into psychology and business vocational pathways respectively. Method: An online self-report survey collected data on levels of psychopathic traits and empathy from 380 newly enrolled first year business and psychology undergraduate students to examine whether these pre-existing personality traits could predict academic discipline attraction and selection. Results: Binary logistic regression analysis partially supported the proposed hypotheses. Cognitive empathy, gender, and social desirability scores were found to be significant predictors of student discipline, with females, those with higher cognitive empathy and lower social desirability scores more likely to be attracted and selected into a psychology rather than a business degree. Small to moderate effect size differences were observed, with psychology students reporting significantly higher cognitive empathy (d = 0.53) and lower interpersonal psychopathy (d = 0.27) than business students. Conclusions: Findings highlight specific personality trait differences present between newly enrolled business and psychology students and the importance of these pre-existing differences in student vocational decision-making. It is anticipated that findings may assist vocational and career counsellors in guiding prospective students in the direction of a vocational pathway that is best suited to their personality, as this is likely to result in increased student satisfaction and selfesteem whilst reducing student attrition. K E Y W O R D Seducational psychology, empathy, individual differences, personality, psychology and other disciplines, psychopathy

Big Five personality trait differences between students from different majors aspiring to the teaching profession

“…Roloff Henoch et al (2015) compared STEM students with non-STEM students, finding that STEM students scored lower on extraversion and openness and higher on conscientiousness. Variations between students with different majors could also be revealed using other personality concepts such as the Dark Triad of personality (Litten et al, 2020;Vedel & Thomsen, 2017).…”

Finding psychopaths in white-collar jobs: a review of the evidence and why it matters

“…Corporate psychopaths are not of limited influence like members of lower social economic classes. Primary psychopaths are more likely to go into university to study business (Litten et al, 2020), and this indicates their interest in the material rewards of a corporate career. Once established in organisational roles, their political and networking skills help their further advancement (Kholin et al, 2020) as they look attractive to human relations practitioners (HR because of their appearance and apparent effectiveness (Hill and Scott, 2019), and consequently there are more corporate psychopaths at the top of organisations (Babiak et al, 2010) To successfully address existential threats posed by leaders, employee groups need a good level of integration if they are to successfully engage in concerted action to counter those threats (Schein, 1983).…”

KAPODI- The Searchable Database of 364 Available Emotional Stimuli Sets

“…Additionally, latter are often Psychology students. A study investigating personality traits and values between business and psychology students reports significantly higher cognitive empathy for psychology students compared to business students (Litten et al, 2020). Further, neuroimaging research suggests many shared areas and a positive relation between the cognitive understanding and the perception of emotions (Mitchell & Phillips, 2015).…”