Empathy in vaccination counselling: a survey on the impact of a three-day residential course

Abstract

Background : In an era of hesitance to use vaccines, the importance of effective communication for increasing vaccine acceptance is well known. This study aimed to assess the impact of a three-day residential course concerning empathy and counselling abilities on patients’ ratings of the level of empathy of physicians and nurses working in vaccination centers. Methods : The empathy of healthcare providers was evaluated using the Adapted Consultation and Relational Empathy (CARE) Measure. The survey involved 20 healthcare workers, doctors, and nurses in three immunization services of a Local Health Unit in South Italy. Before and after attending the course, all of them administered the questionnaire to 50 consecutive parents of vaccinated children. Statistical tests were used to assess the homogeneity of pre- and post -course samples, to measure the level of empathy perceived by parents in doctors and nurses in pre- and post-course evaluations, and to compare the average CARE Measure scores among groups. Results : Analysis of the questionnaires showed an increase of “excellent” scores and statistically significant differences between the pre- and post -course median values. Statistically significant differences between doctors and nurses were shown in almost all questions pre-course and in only four questions post-course. Conclusions : This study demonstrated that a residential course is effective at improving patient-rated empathy of doctors and nurses working in vaccination centers and could result in an increase of parents’ adherence to vaccination programs.

Adverse Events Following Measles-Mumps-Rubella-Varicella Vaccination and the Case of Seizures: A Post Marketing Active Surveillance in Puglia Italian Region, 2017–2018

“…Response rate (84.6%) was consistent with literature data: in a recent study published by Regan A.K. et al, response rate to text messaging and oral voice telephone interviews for AEFIs detection ranged between 63.9% and 90.1%, depending on the age and sociodemographic characteristics of the enrolled people [36,37].…”

Post-Marketing Active Surveillance of Adverse Reactions Following Influenza Cell-Based Quadrivalent Vaccine: An Italian Prospective Observational Study

“…One of the strengths of our study is the value of the response rate (94%), which is higher than the one reported by similar studies (ranging from 63% to 90%) [ 24 , 25 ]. Moreover, the homogeneous sample allowed studying the safety of the vaccine on a specific subgroup population.…”

The Role of Emotional Competences in Parents’ Vaccine Hesitancy

“…To this end, it is important to highlight that emotional competences are conceptualized as abilities that can be taught and learned [ 20 ]. Some findings suggest that healthcare professionals can improve their empathy in vaccination counselling sessions [ 52 ] and that dialogue-based interventions that embrace parents’ perspectives (such as motivational interviewing) are promising in addressing vaccine hesitancy and fostering vaccine uptake [ 53 , 54 ]. From this perspective, future research should explore the impact of increasing parents’ emotional competences.…”