“…Interestingly, a radical species was also observed when the enal was subjected to the standard conditions but without the addition of dioxindole (Scheme 4, spectrum b), which confirms the generation of the homoenolate radical from enal in the presence of NHC and nitrobenzene. 8,17 In addition, an essentially identical EPR signal was observed for the real reaction mixture (Scheme 4, spectrum c).…”