The hangman motif provides mechanistic insights into the role of pendant proton relays in governing proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) involved in the hydrogen evolution reaction (HER). We now show improved HER activity of Ni compared with Co hangman porphyrins. Cyclic voltammogram data and simulations, together with computational studies using density functional theory, implicate a shift in electrokinetic zone between Co and Ni hangman porphyrins due to a change in the PCET mechanism. Unlike the Co hangman porphyrin, the Ni hangman porphyrin does not require reduction to the formally metal(0) species before protonation by weak acids in acetonitrile. We conclude that protonation likely occurs at the Ni(I) state followed by reduction, in a stepwise proton transfer-electron transfer pathway. Spectroelectrochemical and computational studies reveal that upon reduction of the Ni(II) compound, the first electron is transferred to a metal-based orbital, whereas the second electron is transferred to a molecular orbital on the porphyrin ring.renewable | solar fuels | electrocatalysis S olar-to-fuels conversions provide a path to harnessing the ubiquitous albeit intermittent renewable energy resource offered by the sun (1-6). Efficient catalysis of transformations of energy consequence (7-13) mandates the coupling of electron transfer (ET) to proton transfer (PT) in proton-coupled electron transfer (PCET) reactions (14)(15)(16)(17)(18)(19)(20). In the absence of PCET, intermediates possessing equilibrium potentials that are prohibitively large depreciate the storage capacity offered by the solarto-fuels conversion process. The coupling of protons to changes in electron equivalency offers the possibility of restricting the equilibrium potentials of the redox steps to a more narrow potential range, thereby minimizing the overpotential required to sustain catalysis at a desired turnover rate. Thus, the exploitation of PCET pathways to permit potential-leveling effects is a crucial prerequisite for the efficient catalytic conversion reactions of energy relevant molecules.PCET reactions may be classified into stepwise and concerted pathways (14,16,20,21). Stepwise PCET may involve ET first followed by PT (ETPT), or PT followed by ET (PTET). In concerted proton-electron transfers (CPET), the proton and electron traverse a common transition state. Whereas concerted pathways avoid the formation of thermodynamically costly intermediates, CPET reactions may incur kinetic penalties associated with the requirements for proton tunneling (19,20,22). The competition between these dynamics during catalysis determines the most efficient route of reaction. Studies that explore the interplay between these factors are crucial to designing catalytic reactions of high efficiency. Along these lines, the incorporation of proton relays in the second coordination sphere of molecular catalysts has emerged as a useful tool in optimizing PCET transformations (23-29). We have focused on the synthesis and mechanistic investigation of a class of me...