Ethical issues of incorporating spiritual care into clinical practice

Abstract

Aims and objectives. The aim of this article was to analyse the scholarly discourse on the ethical issues of incorporating spirituality and religion into clinical practice. Background. Spirituality is an important aspect of health care, yet the secularisation of health care presents ethical concerns for many health providers. Health providers may have conflicting views regarding if and how to offer spiritual care in the clinical setting. Design. Discursive paper.Results. The discourse analysis uncovered four themes: ethical concerns of omission; ethical concerns of commission; conditions under which health providers prefer to offer spiritual care; and strategies to integrate spiritual care. Ethical concerns of omission of spiritual care include lack of beneficence for not offering holistic care. Ethical concerns of commission are coercion and overstepping one's competence in offering spiritual care. Conditions under which providers are more likely to offer spiritual care are if the patient has a terminal illness, and if the patient requests spiritual care. Strategies for appropriate spiritual care include listening, and remaining neutral and sensitive to spiritual issues. Conclusions. Health providers must be aware of both the concerns of omission and commission. Aristotle's golden mean, an element of virtue ethics, supports a more moderate approach that can be achieved by avoiding the imposition of one's own personal beliefs of a religious persuasion or beliefs of extreme secularisation, and focusing on the beneficence to the patient. Relevance to clinical practice. Key components for health providers in addressing spiritual concerns are self-reflection, provision of individualised care, cultural competency and communication.

Nurse opinions about initiating spiritual conversation and prayer in patient care

“…Following on mandates of nursing codes of ethics, Fowler et al (2012) argued that the power differential in the nursepatient relationship needs to be taken into consideration when providing spiritual or religious care. Although unwelcome spiritual care would be unethical, it is recognized that failure to provide appropriate spiritual care also is unethical (Pesut & Thorne, 2007;Polzer Casarez & Engebretson, 2012;Fowler et al, 2012).…”

Responding to religious patients: why physicians have no business doing theology

“…2 Also Polzer Casarez and Engebretson equate 'the totally secular side' of healthcare with 'imposing his (the physician's) views of religion (that of denial or atheism)' on the patient. 16 Similarly, Bishop accuses liberalism of viewing traditional religious practices as blocking us 'from seeing the pure principles of ethics'. 17 of spiritual care in medical contexts.…”

Effect of the “Spiritual Support” Intervention on Spirituality and the Clinical Parameters of Women Who Have Undergone Mastectomy: A Pilot Study

“…As regards the relevance of nurses focusing more on spiritual aspects in patient care, the literature [30] indicates the importance of including the spirituality domain in nursing care. Researchers [31] have identified that at least 80% of cancer patients would like to participate in spiritual care activities.…”