Ethical Practice in the Contemporary Human Services

Abstract

This paper examines the findings of an exploratory study of emerging ethical issues and practices reported by a sample of human service managers and practitioners in public and non-profit agencies in Queensland, Australia.• Findings: The contemporary context in which human services are delivered in Western societies is characterized by increased marketization, contractualism and managerialist practices, all of which entail different ethical values from those traditionally embraced by the social work profession. Utilizing qualitative and quantitative methodologies, this research identifies current and emerging challenges to ethical practice and existing organizational responses to it. Widespread concern about the negative aspects of changed structural arrangements on ethical practice in the contemporary human services is highlighted. Differences in the ways in which organizations and practitioners are responding to these changes are examined. The limitations of existing approaches and ethics codes are noted. • Applications: Implications for organizations, practitioners and educators are explored, and more pro-active management and training strategies are advocated. Further research is required to identify the often-understated negative effects on ethical practice of the market-based reforms of human service structures and processes.Keywords ethical practice human services managerialism marketization social work 345

The Social Construction of Social Work Ethics: Politicizing and Broadening the Lens

“…Evidence-based and competency-based practices have reduced complex skills to component-measurable parts, and proceduralism has led to the dominance of social work as a rational-technical rather than a practical-moral activity (Parton, 2000) in which practitioners operate as technicians rather than with the autonomy that befits a professional group. Most significantly from the standpoint of ethics, by the emphasizing the value of the marketplace, with efficiency and effectiveness dominating needs and care, the underlying values of social inclusion and entitlements have been eroded (Dominelli, 1999;Lonne, McDonald & Fox, 2004).…”

On the evidence for viruses in social work systems: law, ethics and practice

“…From a US context, Madden (2007) argues that managers must know legal standards in order to structure the use of discretion and analyse practice decisions. Research from Australia (Lonne et al, 2004), the US (Strom-Gottfried, 2000), and Europe (Musil et al, 2004;Papadaki & Papadaki, 2008) reports unsettling evidence about the impact of organisational procedures on workers and the erosion of ethical practice.…”

Impasses éthiques des politiques sociales d’activation1

“…Les traits communs de ces derniers, malgré les formes diverses qu'ils ont prises selon les pays (Esping-Andersen, 1990;Ferragina et Seeleib-Kaiser, 2011), se mesurent d'ailleurs à l'aune des transformations opérées entre 1990 et 2010. Le virage politique récemment opéré vers la mise en exergue de la responsabilité individuelle, en Amérique du Nord (Hacker, 2006), en Océanie (Lonne, McDonald et Fox, 2004) et en Europe (Van Oorschot, 2006;Hache, 2007;Franssen, 2008), montre en quoi les politiques sociales progressivement déployées au cours du XX e siècle reposaient davantage sur une redistribution des richesses (plus ou moins large), et sur une conception plus collective des responsabilités reliées aux problèmes sociaux -que ce soit sur le plan de l'explication de leurs origines ou des réponses à leur apporter. Comme le souligne Wim Van Oorschot à propos des politiques sociales danoises : « The system not only has lost part of its solidaristic character, it also turned less collective.…”

“…Une perte de confiance vis-à-vis de l'institution est exprimée de manière récurrente : Saint-Arnaud, 2011). Elles rejoignent également les résultats de recherches menées dans le secteur de la santé en France (Molinier, 2004;Cintas, 2007 Ces formes de perte de confiance des intervenants.es vis-à-vis de leur institution, que Merlinda Weinberg analyse sous l'angle de la détresse morale, ont une dimension internationale puisqu'on les observe également en France (Dejours, 2006), en Australie (Lonne, McDonald et Fox, 2004), etc. Ces différents travaux documentent la dimension qui a disparu du cadre d'évaluation EGIPSS, appliqué au système de santé et de services sociaux, à savoir celle devant estimer le « consensus sur les valeurs du système et le climat organisationnel » (CSBE, 2005 : 17).…”