Ethnic Identity and Orientation to White American Culture Are Linked to Well-Being Among American Indians – But in Different Ways

Abstract

This study examined the relationship between ethnic identity, orientation toward the White mainstream culture, and psychological well-being among American Indians. In the light of the unique history of American Indians, we investigated the relationship between identification with the American Indian ingroup, orientation toward the dominant White American culture (in terms of showing behavior typical for White mainstream culture as well as positive attitudes and feelings of belonging to White American culture), and self-efficacy and learned helplessness as indicators of psychological well-being. Structural equation analyses with an adolescent and an adult sample revealed a positive relationship between ethnic identity and self-efficacy but no link with learned helplessness. The tendency to show behavior typical for White mainstream culture was associated with higher self-efficacy in both samples and with lower helplessness in the adult subsample. White American orientation in the form of positive attitudes and sense of belonging were associated with higher helplessness in both samples and with lower self-efficacy among adults. The findings are discussed in terms of the role of both ethnic identity and the orientation toward the mainstream culture for well-being among American Indians, focusing on the distinct relations of White American behavior versus White American affiliation with well-being in American Indians.

Broadening Conceptualization of Native Identity as Foundational for Success among Native Americans in STEM

“…These identity dynamics play-out in the documented educational experience of Native Americans. The academic literature demonstrates that a strong connection to Native culture has been shown to be associated with academic success [17,36,40,[44][45][46][47][48]. Our research builds on these works and on an emerging literature conceptualizing identity issues in relation to STEM education [30,[48][49][50].…”

“…Their cultural identity becomes an anchor and a source of strength. Schiefer and Krahé [44] found that Native Americans who have a strong self-association as Native have more confidence in their own internal resources. Huffman [40,41] similarly conceptualizes ways that a strong sense of ethnic identity provides emotional security for Native Americans to operate in non-Native contexts.…”

“I don’t do it for myself, I do it for them”: A grounded theory study of South Asians’ experiences of making lifestyle change after myocardial infarction

“…Walters and Simoni (2002) identified cultural practices and the inclusion of family and community as protective factors that can buffer, or mediate, negative mental and emotional outcomes in the face of stress and trauma. Numerous cultural factors including but not limited to, involvement in cultural activities, and spirituality have been linked previously to positive mental and behavioural health outcomes (Carlson & González-Prendes, 2016;Schiefer & Krahé, 2014). Furthermore, Guo and Harris (2016) reported that the experience of making adjustments and adopting lifestyle changes following acute coronary syndrome was influenced by subjective life experiences in conjunction with individual, sociocultural and environmental contexts.…”

Music and Acculturation: Using Culture-focused Music Therapy to Address the Adverse Effects of Acculturative Stress

“…Garret and Pichette (2000) defined the process starkly as a campaign to "kill the Indian, save the man" (p. 4). This truly deplorable historical fate carried over across multiple generations, and when paired with the present day landscape of acculturative stress factors, prejudice and discrimination, the Native American sense of identification and well-being is profoundly affected (Schiefer & Krahé, 2014).…”

“…Also of potential concern is the population focus of the literature dealing with acculturation. Acculturation research has largely focused on a few specific population groups of immigrants (Schiefer & Krahé, 2014). Though this research is vastly important, it is also important to understand how acculturation affects a diversity of people.…”