Evaluation of Atmospheric Correction Algorithms for Sentinel-2-MSI and Sentinel-3-OLCI in Highly Turbid Estuarine Waters

Abstract

The present study assesses the performance of state-of-the-art atmospheric correction (AC) algorithms applied to Sentinel-2-MultiSpectral Instrument (S2-MSI) and Sentinel-3-Ocean and Land Color Instrument (S3-OLCI) data recorded over moderately to highly turbid estuarine waters, considering the Gironde Estuary (SW France) as a test site. Three spectral bands of water-leaving reflectance ( R h o w ) are considered: green (560 nm), red (655 or 665 nm) and near infrared (NIR) (865 nm), required to retrieve the suspended particulate matter (SPM) concentrations in clear to highly turbid waters (SPM ranging from 1 to 2000 mg/L). A previous study satisfactorily validated Acolite short wave infrared (SWIR) AC algorithm for Landsat-8-Operational Land Imager (L8-OLI) in turbid estuarine waters. The latest version of Acolite Dark Spectrum Fitting (DSF) is tested here and shows very good agreement with Acolite SWIR for OLI data. L8-OLI satellite data corrected for atmospheric effects using Acolite DSF are then used as a reference to assess the validity of atmospheric corrections applied to other satellite data recorded over the same test site with a minimum time difference. Acolite DSF and iCOR (image correction for atmospheric effects) are identified as the best performing AC algorithms among the tested AC algorithms (Acolite DSF, iCOR, Polymer and C2RCC (case 2 regional coast color)) for S2-MSI. Then, the validity of six different AC algorithms (OLCI Baseline Atmospheric Correction (BAC), iCOR, Polymer, Baseline residual (BLR), C2RCC-V1 and C2RCC-V2) applied to OLCI satellite data is assessed based on comparisons with OLI and/or MSI Acolite DSF products recorded on a same day with a minimum time lag. Results show that all the AC algorithms tend to underestimate R h o w in green, red and NIR bands except iCOR in green and red bands. The iCOR provides minimum differences in green (slope = 1.0 ± 0.15, BIAS = 1.9 ± 4.5% and mean absolute percentage error (MAPE) = 12 ± 5%) and red (slope = 1.0 ± 0.17, BIAS = −9.8 ± 9% and MAPE = 28 ± 20%) bands with Acolite DSF products from OLI and MSI data. For the NIR band, BAC provides minimum differences (slope = 0.7 ± 0.13, BIAS = −33 ± 17% and MAPE = 55 ± 20%) with Acolite DSF products from OLI and MSI data. These results based on comparisons between almost simultaneous satellite products are supported by match-ups between satellite-derived and field-measured SPM concentrations provided by automated turbidity stations. Further validation of satellite products based on rigorous match-ups with in-situ R h o w measurements is still required in highly turbid waters.

Towards the Combination of C2RCC Processors for Improving Water Quality Retrieval in Inland and Coastal Areas

“…Atmospheric correction in case-2 waters has not been solved yet. As a result, huge efforts have been made to develop atmospheric correction processors, covering a wide range of different methods [11][12][13]. However, the performance of the processors may differ depending on the scenario (sun and observation geometry, atmospheric, optical, and site-specific conditions), and there is no standardized approach yet, but atmospheric correction processors keep evolving as new approaches and more data become available.…”

Consistency between Satellite Ocean Colour Products under High Coloured Dissolved Organic Matter Absorption in the Baltic Sea

“…This is linked to errors in the AC aerosol type and load [7]. There is a need to extend the validation of OLCI to optically complex, extreme absorbing and scattering waters, where the retrieval of L w can be even more problematic [8]. The high absorption, low scattering waters of semi-enclosed seas, such as the Baltic, Black and Yellow Seas, Arctic Ocean and coastal regions adjacent to the largest rivers such as the Amazon, are some of the most challenging regions to obtain accurate and reliable ocean colour data.…”

Using Copernicus Sentinel-2 and Sentinel-3 data to monitor harmful algal blooms in Southern Chile during the COVID-19 lockdown

“…9). This algorithm has been already validated in several areas with optical complex waters (Caballero et al, 2018(Caballero et al, , 2019Renosh et al, 2020), as in other studies about flagellates as Lingulodinium polyedra by Caballero et al (2020). Landsat satellites do not have bands in the red-edge spectral range (700-720 nm).…”