Evaluation of gene expression measurements from commercial microarray platforms

Abstract

Multiple commercial microarrays for measuring genome-wide gene expression levels are currently available, including oligonucleotide and cDNA, single- and two-channel formats. This study reports on the results of gene expression measurements generated from identical RNA preparations that were obtained using three commercially available microarray platforms. RNA was collected from PANC-1 cells grown in serum-rich medium and at 24 h following the removal of serum. Three biological replicates were prepared for each condition, and three experimental replicates were produced for the first biological replicate. RNA was labeled and hybridized to microarrays from three major suppliers according to manufacturers' protocols, and gene expression measurements were obtained using each platform's standard software. For each platform, gene targets from a subset of 2009 common genes were compared. Correlations in gene expression levels and comparisons for significant gene expression changes in this subset were calculated, and showed considerable divergence across the different platforms, suggesting the need for establishing industrial manufacturing standards, and further independent and thorough validation of the technology.

Microarray analysis to evaluate different animal models for human heart failure

“…Affymetrix and in-house produced arrays). As reported in several studies expression profiling of the same biological material but using different array platforms delivers data sets with alarmingly poor overlap [12] (Fig. 2).…”

Are expression profiles meaningless for cancer studies?

“…They have also been promoted as tools for prognosis, indicating the probable evolution of a cancer and, in some cases, for prediction of the efficacy of a given therapy. Early technical problems [3,4] were progressively controlled [5]. At the same time, the somewhat questionable statistical procedures initially used to derive clinically oriented 'signatures' were analysed critically [6,7] and largely replaced by more rigorous methods.…”

Chroniques génomiques

“…Mais ces travaux ont fait l'objet de nombreuses critiques [2][3][4]. Au début, il s'est surtout agi de relever les imperfections techniques.…”