Evaluation of Modeling Approaches to Determine End‐of‐Life Flows Associated with Buildings: A Viennese Case Study on Wood and Contaminants

Abstract

Dynamic material flow analysis enables the forecasting of secondary raw material potential for waste volumes in future periods, by assessing past, present, and future stocks and flows of materials in the anthroposphere. Analyses of waste streams of buildings stocks are uncertain with respect to data and model structure. Wood construction in Viennese buildings serve as a case study to compare different modeling approaches for determining end-of-life (EoL) wood and corresponding contaminant flows (lead, chlorine, and polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons). A delayed input and a leaching stock modeling approach are used to determine wood stocks and flows from 1950 until 2100. Cross-checking with independent estimates and sensitivity analyses are used to evaluate the results' plausibility. In the situation of the given data in the present case study, the delay approach is a better choice for historical observations of EoL wood and for analyses at a substance level. It has some major drawbacks for future predictions at the goods level, though, as the durability of a large number of historical buildings with considerably higher wood content is not reflected in the model. The wood content parameter differs strongly for the building periods and has therefore the highest influence on the results. Based on this knowledge, general recommendations can be derived for analyses on waste flows of buildings at a goods and substance level. Keywords:building stock modeling contaminants dynamic material flow analysis (MFA) end-of-life wood industrial ecology uncertainty analysis Supporting information is linked to this article on the JIE website Conflict of interest statement: The authors have no conflict to declare.

Spatiotemporally Explicit Mapping of Built Environment Stocks Reveals Two Centuries of Urban Development in a Fairytale City, Odense, Denmark

“…We employed the uncertainty evaluation method suggested by Hedbrant and Sörme (and applied by Džubur and Laner and Guo et al ) to discuss data source uncertainty. As shown in Supporting Information Section 6, the uncertainty level for the four key attributes (location, shape, end use, and floor number) of buildings were retrieved or estimated according to visible characteristics or information on the maps or images.…”

Combining the worlds of energy systems and material flow analysis: a review

“…A typical goal of MFAs is how certain material flows affect waste streams or how, in dynamics MFAs, consumption behavior affects resource stocks over time. MFAs are modeled for small regions [68], on a national scale [69] and at the global level [70], but foremost for a single specific material or product group only [71]. Depending on the scope of the study, MFAs are used for industrial process assessment, policy evaluation or large-scale environmental assessment.…”

“…2) while only one of all the reviewed models quantifies the flows and stocks on a communal scale. Dzubur et al [68] compare different modeling approaches to account for secondary raw material flows in the Viennese wood construction sector. They point out that varying the wood content in different construction periods increases data uncertainty and complicates predictions of future secondary wood flows.…”

A product–component framework for modeling stock dynamics and its application for electric vehicles and lithium‐ion batteries

“…Furthermore, Sandberg et al (2014) proposed to consider renovation profiles in buildings to account for changes in the energy intensity of the existing stock, by introducing renovation cycles coupled with the survival curve of the stock-type-cohort matrix. Džubur & Laner (2018) addresses the role of renovation, which can be understood as a critical component of buildings, by adding the demolition and renovation rates in a leaching compared to a lifetime approach. This was further developed by Roca-Puigròs et al (2020), who proposed a combined lifetime and leaching approach to model the effect of early demolition and renovation strategies for old buildings.…”