This paper is the result of a collaborative work between researchers based in UK, Italy, China and Brazil, and aims at providing a comprehensive review of practices and meanings of Non--Invasive Prenatal Testing (NIPT) in these countries, while also highlighting the ethical implications that NIPT poses. In the first part of this paper we describe how the technology is being integrated into the 'moral economy' of prenatal testing in the different countries we analysed. The uses of NIPT differ greatly in the countries we analysed.In the second section of the paper we position NIPT within the trajectory of prenatal diagnosis that, displays the role of conflicting values and often incommensurable moral economies in the emergence of new technologies, and in their transformation into routine medical procedures. The two 'often incommensurable moral economies' are women's autonomy and individual--centred medicine, as emphasised in gynaecologists and midwives/obstetricians' public discourse; and considerations about the cost/efficacy of long--term care for people with Down Syndrome or other chromosomal--related disabilities as emphasized in public health discourses. We discuss how these two contrasting narratives are also at play (more or less covertly) in the discourses around NIPT. We then consider some of the ethical issues raised by NIPT, including the argument that NIPT will lead to a harmful bias towards people with Down Syndrome and to an increase in termination rates; and the ethical issues raised possible incidental findings resulting from a maternal chromosomal mosaicisms due to an anomalous cellular line, and other hidden abnormalities in one of the parents, including genetic diseases with late expressions in life. We note how the counselling step following incidental finding will be of the utmost importance and that in many countries, including the ones we analysed, doctors and healthcare professionals are not adequately prepared for it. We conclude that it is important that bioethics scholarship engages proactively with the ethical issues that arise at the nexus of these conflicting values and moral economies, especially as future evolutions of NIPT combined with whole genome sequencing (WGS) will affect women's reproductive decisions, and shape the scope of their reproductive choices, in a way that will lead to a completely new level of 'supervision', 'management' and 'scrutiny' of human foetuses and pregnant women.
Accepted for publication June 30, 2016 Forthcoming September 20163
French key--words (Mot--clefs): diagnostique prénatal, tests prénataux non invasifs, NIPT, maladie génétique French AbstractCet article est le résultat d'une collaboration entre des chercheurs qui ont étudié l'évolution du diagnostique prénatal au Royaume Uni, en Italie, en Chine et au Brésil. Il passe en revue les pratiques liées à l'introduction des tests prénataux non invasifs (NIPT) dans ces pays, et discute les questions éthiques liées à l'introduction de cette nouvelle approche diagnostique. En Chine, en Italie, au Royaume ...