Evaluation of winter cover crop methods for management of flatheaded appletree borer (Coleoptera: Buprestidae)

Abstract

Winter cover crops grown at the base of red maples (Acer rubrum L.) can reduce flatheaded appletree borer (Chrysobothris femorata Olivier; Coleoptera: Buprestidae; FAB) damage by both physically blocking preferred oviposition sites and altering the environment around them. However, cover crop competition negatively affects tree growth. To investigate long-term cover crop effects, trees grown with cover crop for 2 yr were transitioned to a standard herbicide practice. After 4 yr, trees in the initial 2 yr cover crop plots were 1 yr behind in growth compared to trees grown in bare rows for all 4 yr. Most growth reduction occurred in the first year following transplant. Additional borer losses of 1–2% per year were observed in production years 3 and 4. A second experiment answered 2 questions: Can killing the cover crop once it reaches maximal height protect trees from borers while also reducing competition and thereby increase tree growth? and Do herbicide applications increase borer attacks? In this experiment, red maples were grown with (i) a standard herbicide program, (ii) a mulch mat, (iii) a cover crop that was killed early, or (iv) a cover crop allowed to senesce naturally. Evaluations after 2 yr indicated early kill of the cover crop was not enough to improve tree growth. Further, trees in the early kill cover crop treatment had the most FAB attacks. Cover crops allowed to senesce naturally reduced FAB attacks in both studies; however, more work is needed to minimize disparities in tree growth during the initial year post-transplant and determine the causal relationship between herbicide use and borer attacks.