Evidence for multiple drivers of aerial insectivore declines in North America

Abstract

Aerial insectivores (birds that forage on aerial insects) have experienced significant population declines in North America. Numerous hypotheses have been proposed for these declines, but current evidence suggests multiple factors could be operating in combination during their annual migratory cycles between breeding and nonbreeding areas. Potential drivers include decreased prey abundance, direct or indirect impacts of environmental contaminants, habitat loss, phenological changes due to warming climate, and conditions on migratory stopover or wintering grounds. While no single threat appears to be the cause of aerial insectivore declines, existing evidence suggests that several of these factors could be contributing to the declines at different times in the annual lifecycle. Breeding productivity for most of these species does not appear to be limited by overall prey abundance, contaminants, or habitat loss, which suggests that similar issues on nonbreeding grounds or carryover effects could play important roles. However, a better understanding of the importance of prey quality throughout the lifecycle is critically needed. Based on current evidence, we propose that changes in availability of high-quality prey, with variability across breeding and nonbreeding grounds, reduce various combinations of fledging success, post-fledging survival, and nonbreeding season body condition of aerial insectivores, resulting in species and geographic differences in population trends. We encourage others to use this hypothesis as a starting point to test specific mechanisms by which availability of high-quality prey influences demographic parameters. We suggest that future research focus on defining prey quality, monitoring insect abundance in conjunction with birds, comparing demographic models across local populations experiencing different population growth rates, and using tracking technology to document important migratory and nonbreeding areas. Considerable research progress already has been made, but additional research is needed to better understand the complex web of potential causes driving aerial insectivore declines.

Nutritional consequences of breeding away from riparian habitats in Bank Swallows: new evidence from multiple endogenous markers

“…We advocate formal consideration of nutrition in the conservation and management of species. While it is generally recognized that food availability is an important component of suitable habitat, understanding prey quality and distribution formally in terms of ‘nutritional landscapes’ could aid in animal conservation ( Twining et al , 2016b , 2018a ; Rubin et al , 2019 ; Spiller and Dettmers, 2019 ). Our study shows the importance of conserving high-quality lakeshore habitats and supporting productive aquatic insect emergences.…”

Further evidence for a global decline of the entomofauna

“…They equally constitute vital food sources for numerous vertebrates and underpin the functioning and integrity of entire ecosystems. Calls for more robust and better datasets, longer time horizons or a more exhaustive analysis of the underlying drivers should not be an excuse for delaying or refraining from action on an urgent issue that is essential for the survival of the world's ecosystems (Spiller and Dettmers 2019; Harvey et al . 2020).…”

Predator preferences shape the diets of arthropodivorous bats more than quantitative local prey abundance

“…Arrizabalaga‐Escudero et al, 2019; Vesterinen et al, 2016). As many arthropodivorous vertebrates, particularly birds and bats, are currently threatened due to habitat loss, arthropod declines and disease, among other factors (Nebel et al, 2010; O'Shea et al, 2016; Rioux Paquette et al, 2014; Spiller & Dettmers, 2019), fully characterizing their resource requirements also represents a timely endeavour.…”