Four theridiid spiders of the genus Steatoda are present in New Zealand: S. truncata (Urquhart) 1887 and S. lepida (Cambridge) 1879, which are endemic; S. grossa (Koch) 1838, a cosmopolitan species; and S. capensis Hann, 1990, a South African species. The synonymy of S. regia (Marples) 1956 with S. lepida is recognised. Theridium truncatum Urquhart, 1887 is recognised as a valid species within Steatoda, and the male is described here for the first time. The four species are described, diagnostic features illustrated, and ecological information given where possible. A fifth record, for S. nubilosa Urquhart, 1892, is rejected.