“…Second, 3D atomic quantum simulations, e.g., [12,13], involve separating the nonlinear response from the much larger linear response in the full optical response, and this can be prone to numerical issues. It was recently shown in [14] that the 1D atomic model allows for an exact solution for the nonlinear optical response, making it immune to numerical issues, so that qualitative comparison between the more precise 3D atomic model and the reduced 1D atomic model can serve to bolster the conclusions of [11,12].Our diagnostic approach involves a pump-probe scheme involving the electric field profile shown in Fig. 1.…”