Examining the effectiveness of place-based interventions to improve public health and reduce health inequalities: an umbrella review

Abstract

Background Locally delivered, place-based public health interventions are receiving increasing attention as a way of improving health and reducing inequalities. However, there is limited evidence on their effectiveness. This umbrella review synthesises systematic review evidence of the health and health inequalities impacts of locally delivered place-based interventions across three elements of place and health: the physical, social, and economic environments. Methods Systematic review methodology was used to identify recent published systematic reviews of the effectiveness of place-based interventions on health and health inequalities (PROGRESS+) in high-income countries. Nine databases were searched from 1st January 2008 to 1st March 2020. The quality of the included articles was determined using the Revised Assessment of Multiple Systematic Reviews tool (R-AMSTAR). Results Thirteen systematic reviews were identified - reporting 51 unique primary studies. Fifty of these studies reported on interventions that changed the physical environment and one reported on changes to the economic environment. Only one primary study reported cost-effectiveness data. No reviews were identified that assessed the impact of social interventions. Given heterogeneity and quality issues, we found tentative evidence that the provision of housing/home modifications, improving the public realm, parks and playgrounds, supermarkets, transport, cycle lanes, walking routes, and outdoor gyms – can all have positive impacts on health outcomes – particularly physical activity. However, as no studies reported an assessment of variation in PROGRESS+ factors, the effect of these interventions on health inequalities remains unclear. Conclusions Place-based interventions can be effective at improving physical health, health behaviours and social determinants of health outcomes. High agentic interventions indicate greater improvements for those living in greater proximity to the intervention, which may suggest that in order for interventions to reduce inequalities, they should be implemented at a scale commensurate with the level of disadvantage. Future research needs to ensure equity data is collected, as this is severely lacking and impeding progress on identifying interventions that are effective in reducing health inequalities. Trial registration PROSPERO CRD42019158309

Impacts of a workplace-based weight-control intervention on objective and perceived physical activity among a subgroup of workers

“…Data were not collected on the participants' home and neighborhood environments, which limits the understanding of broader potential impacts on PA behaviors. However, there is ample evidence of the importance of neighborhood environments (Kepper et al, 2019;Smith et al, 2017) and activity and the importance of place-based interventions to reduce health inequities (McGowan et al, 2021). In addition, lower income workers are more likely to be facing barriers outside the workplace (e.g., financial, environmental or social stressors) which can take precedence over preventive behaviors (Kreuter et al, 2016;Thompson et al, 2019).…”

Effectiveness of Complaint Services at the Talise Health Center Regional Technical Implementation Unit

“…The "exit" mechanism means that if public services are of poor quality, consumers must have the opportunity to choose another public service provider that they like. While the "voice" mechanism means that there is an opportunity to express dissatisfaction to the public service provider institution [5] [6].…”

The Wellbeing In Place Perceptions Scale: Structure, Validity, Reliability and Correlates during COVID times.

“…The role of place-based factors in determining physical and mental health and wellbeing is now well established, rendering the association beyond doubt e.g. (Farrell, Aubry & Coulombe, 2004;Klein, 2004;Bernarda et al, 2007;McGowan et al, 2021). Recent initiatives such as the establishment of Marmot communities in the UK is testament to the importance of tackling these wider social, economic and environmental determinants to address population health and wellbeing and their unequal distribution nationally and internationally.…”