Nacre with its brick and mortar architecture continues to be one role model for such composites, which are tackled by several preparation routes to realize highly reinforced nanocomposites (>50 wt% of platelets), including layer-by-layer (LbL), [6] multi-layer deposition, [7] filtration, [8-11] directional freezing, [12-14] 3D printing, [15] and evaporative self-assembly. [16,17] Such methods vary in terms of time-consumption, scalability, and total amount of steps, yet still provide an efficient and controllable structure. Additionally, different reinforcements have been useful to provide a nacrelike structure, among them, clays, [11,16,18,19] graphene, [20-22] mxene, [10,23] glass, [8,9] lignocellulose, [14] and even polymer-based systems. [24,25] Furthermore, the variation of the size and aspect ratio (d/t) of the reinforcement has allowed to obtain control over the structure formation, deformation mechanisms, and mechanical properties, demonstrating the importance of a precise architecture. [17] Finally, the design of the soft-phase polymer matrix has also been an important focus of study. Traditionally, commercial hydrophilic polymers like polyvinylalcohol (PVA), polyvinylamine (PVAm) or polyethylene oxide (PEO) were used, which however presently limits the understanding as their properties are not tailor-made for understanding the overall mechanical behavior. [17,26,27] Detailed engineering of the polymer structure allowed to introduce new functionalities and dynamics within the internal structure of the nanocomposites through supramolecular bonds in dissociative networks. [21,28,29] Despite these advances, it is interesting to note that there are several fundamentally important issues that have not been addressed at all so far. To date, it is unknown how the glass transition temperature of polymers in a highly reinforced nanoclay/polymer nacre-mimetic with nanoconfined polymer layers would influence the mechanical properties. There have been attempts to discuss these properties by plasticization using swelling with water and humidity, but this also alters the nanoscale periodicities and cohesive interactions. [30,31] A detailed study of the thermo-mechanical behavior in nacremimetic nanocomposites, without the addition of swelling solvent would clearly benefit the research field and improve an understanding of how the polymer properties govern the energy dissipation in the material. Herein we systematically design a copolymer structure able to offer different thermal transitions as a function of the composition, while maintaining overall a non-ionic character to smoothly integrate into nanoclay/ polymer-based nacre-mimetics by film casting and evaporative Although research in bioinspired nanocomposites is delivering mechanically superior nanocomposite materials, there remain gaps in understanding some fundamental design principles. This article discusses how the mechanical properties of nacre-mimetic polymer/nanoclay nanocomposites with nanoconfined polymer layers are controlled by the thermo-mechanical po...