Expensive seems better: The price of a non-effective drug modulates its perceived efficacy

Abstract

Previous studies have shown that the price of a given product impacts the perceived quality of such product. This finding was also observed in medical contexts, showing that expensive drugs increase the placebo effect compared to inexpensive ones. However, addressing a drug's efficacy requires making causal inferences between the drug and the healing. These inferences rely on the contingency between these two events, a factor that is difficult to control in the placebo research. The present study aimed to test whether the price of a given drug modulates its perceived efficacy using a proper (though fictitious) non-effective drug, so that not only the objective contingency, but also the probability of the cause and the probability of the effect could be adequately controlled for. We expected higher efficacy judgements for the expensive non-effective drug than for the inexpensive one. To test this hypothesis, 60 volunteers participated in a contingency learning task that was programmed so that 72% of the patients healed regardless of whether they took the drug. Approximately one-half of the participants were told that the drug was expensive, whereas the other half were told that it was inexpensive. As expected, the efficacy judgements of participants who saw the expensive drug were significantly higher than those who saw the inexpensive one. Overall, our results showed that the price of a non-effective drug modulates its perceived efficacy, an effect that seems to be mediated by the estimated number of doses administered. This result parallels findings in the placebo literature but using a laboratory methodology that allows stronger control of the variables, suggesting that the illusory overestimation produced by the more expensive treatments might be on the basis of the greater efficacy of the more expensive placebos.

Development of Herbal Topical Anesthetic Mucoadhesive Spray for oral Cavity using Customer-Centric Approach

“…Moreover, the price image also affected the purchase intentions of consumers [63]. Consumers believe that expensive medicines are more effective than low-cost medicines [64]. Consumers who purchase products at pharmacies tend to perceive low-priced products as untrustworthy [65], particularly in the case of herbal products.…”

Maternal knowledge and prescribing practices of antibiotics for childhood infections: a cross-sectional survey in Jordan

“…However, it is worth noting that multiple studies have indicated that higher-priced drugs are often associated with higher efficacy judgment. 25 Clearly, new antibiotics have been developed to target more resistant strains of bacteria. Nevertheless, this does not imply that the older antibiotics are any less effective than the new ones against the original strains of bacteria.…”

Cognición extendida y símbolos de la velada mazateca con hongos psilocibios

“…Por ejemplo, se ha documentado que, si se consume un medicamento después de observar algún anuncio que lo publicite, se potencia la respuesta fisiológica para la que fue diseñado (Kamenica et al, 2013). Dado que elementos como el precio, disponibilidad y presentación del fármaco se asocian con su mejor calidad, no sorprende que un placebo costoso, visibilizado y elegantemente empacado genere una mayor respuesta terapéutica (Díaz-Lago et al, 2023). La industria farmacéutica se vale de esta mercadotecnia para argumentar que los medicamentos de patente son más efectivos, pero bien se podría tratar del efecto placebo inducido por la publicidad, el precio y la experiencia de desempacar el producto.…”