We are all created equal, and only circumstance and history make us what we appear to be on the outside. (Wagamese, 2011, p. 81) Sioban Nelson (2009) suggests that there are stories that need to be told. Her words echo in our mind, as we sit quietly and listen to students attempting to understand manifestations of racism and discrimination in nursing practice with Indigenous people, immigrants, and refugees. But it's Richard Wagamese's (2011) words that touch our heart: "We are all created equal, and only circumstance and history make us what we appear to be on the outside" (p. 81). "And history" is a thread that needs to be picked up, as it may very well be essential for the challenging conversations we are having with students today. Racism has deep historical roots in Canada. Rethinking history in this time of reconciliation in Canada, particularly in nursing provides a means to reconsider our conversations with students and to reconsider the history of the profession in relation to reconciliation.