In a previous paper (Jensen et al., J. Am. Chem. Soc. 2005, 127, 10512), we reported the synthesis of the turquoise-colored intermediate [Fe IV (β-BPMCN)(OO t Bu)(OH)] 2+ (Tq; BPMCN = N,N′-bis (2-pyridylmethyl)-N,N′-dimethyl-trans-1,2-diaminocyclohexane). The structure of Tq is unprecedented, as it represents the only synthetic example to date of a non-heme Fe IV complex with both alkylperoxo and hydroxide ligands. Given the significance of similar high-valent Fe intermediates in the mechanisms of oxygenase enzymes, we have explored the reactivity of Tq at −70 °C, a temperature at which it is stable, and found that it is capable of activating weak X-H bonds (X = C, O) with bond dissociation energies ≤~80 kcal/mol. The Fe IV -OH unit of Tq, and not the alkylperoxo moiety, performs the initial H-atom abstraction. However at −45 °C, Tq decays at a rate that is independent of substrate identity and concentration, forming a species capable of oxidizing substrates with stronger C-H bonds. Parallel reactivity studies were also conducted with the related oxoiron(IV) complexes [Fe IV (β-BPMCN)(O)(X)] 2+ (3-X; X = pyridine or nitrile), thereby permitting a direct comparison of the reactivity of Fe IV centers with oxo and hydroxide ligands. We found that the H-atom abstracting ability of the Fe IV =O species greatly exceeds that of the Fe IV -OH species, generally by greater than 100-fold. Examination of the electronic structures of Tq and 3-X with density functional theory (DFT) provides a rationale for their differing reactivities.