Numerous models have been developed to determine the strength contributions of steel fibers in reinforced concrete beams in flexure; however, little work has been undertaken on determining their reliability, particularly when combined with use of inverse analysis procedures for determining the postcracking residual tensile strength provided by the fibers. Recently, leading codes have accepted design guidelines for designing flexurally reinforced concrete structural elements that also contain steel fibers using rational principles that are compatible with conventional reinforced concrete design. To provide confidence to the designer, it is imperative to verify the design models against experimental results and test their reliability. Despite extensive studies, design models have not been validated against large amount of test data. In this paper, 50 flexurally reinforced steel fiber reinforced concrete beams from the literature are analyzed for flexural strength. Ultimate moment capacities are predicted using the design procedures of NZS 3101–2–2006, fib Model Code 2010, DAfStb Guideline‐2015 and AS3600–2018. The results of the analyses show that the models perform well, with the AS3600 being the most conservative of the models assessed, and the NZS 3101–2–2006 the least conservative. The model errors for each are determined, and model reliability is discussed.