Explorative Nature of Negotiation in Participatory Decision Making for Sustainability

Abstract

Land use planning and policy making for environmental systems involve uncertainty, long time scales, and complex socio-natural systems and processes; most decisions are often characterized by conflict and tension and give rise to disagreements which are widely considered and managed as disagreement about socio-environmental values. Although the growing acceptance of participatory models in environmental planning and policy making is forcing the public authorities to implement participatory mechanisms, participation practices are not showing much effectiveness in reducing conflict and tension. This paper argues that negotiation approaches in participatory decision making often pose the attention on disputing actors and their related values (in the field of environmental planning, on socio-environmental values) thus amplifying the risk for conflict to sharpen. Participation practices, in fact, often use Decision and Conflict Analysis models as means to disclose structures of parties' values and preferences to parties themselves, thus risking to enhance sources for conflict and tension. In this article, participation is conceptualized as an exploration process looking for decision 'opportunities' which allow transforming participatory decision making into operational collaboration. To illustrate the discussion we present a case of participatory decision making process in the Torre Guaceto wetland, a Natural Reserve in Southern Italy. The process refers to the formulation of the land use plan and is analysed by the application of a cognitive model. The analysis shows how the negotiation The present article is the result of a collaborative work between the authors; their names are listed alphabetically.A. Celino 123 256 A. Celino, G. Concilio process evolves from a conflict to collaboration and becomes centred on the content of the decision rather than the social and environmental values involved.

Fostering students’ socioscientific decision-making: exploring the effectiveness of an environmental science competition

“…As a result, participants might have felt empowered to share their experiences in this respect. Furthermore, the dynamic interaction between participants and other students potentially inspires a culture of shared decisionmaking, which can bring forward joint actions for sustainable development (Celino & Concilio, 2011).…”

Enabling Adaptive Water Management to Face Drought Risk in a Changing Climate

“…With reference to this, Concilio (2000) highlights that participatory decision-making should be seen as a process of collective exploration of the decision space. Therefore, participation has to be an action-oriented process and is described as a search process looking for negotiation opportunities enabling participatory decision-making (Celino and Concilio 2011). Hence, together with progress in coordination within levels of government, heightened public exposure of bureaucratic processes is crucial since it can promote the construction of more transparent water governance (Adhikari and Tarkowski 2013) favouring information sharing and fostering participation and reducing the room for corruption.…”

The Sustainability Cycle and Loop: Models for a more unified understanding of sustainability

“…As such, Meadows (1998, p.9) highlights that the "very choice of an indicator is based upon some value, some inner human purpose that tells us what is important to measure." In turn, authors have emphasised the importance of involving multiple stakeholders in discussions on SIs (Celino and Concilio 2010;Garmendia and Stagl 2010;Robinson et al 2011;Yang et al 2011), including both expert stakeholders (e.g. natural scientists, sociologists, and engineers), and citizen stakeholders and their representatives (e.g.…”