Exploring perceptions of community health policy in Kenya and identifying implications for policy change

Abstract

Background: Global interest and investment in close-to-community health services is increasing. Kenya is currently revising its community health strategy (CHS) alongside political devolution, which will result in revisioning of responsibility for local services. This article aims to explore drivers of policy change from key informant perspectives and to study perceptions of current community health services from community and sub-county levels, including perceptions of what is and what is not working well. It highlights implications for managing policy change.Methods: We conducted 40 in-depth interviews and 10 focus group discussions with a range of participants to capture plural perspectives, including those who will influence or be influenced by CHS policy change in Kenya (policymakers, sub-county health management teams, facility managers, community health extension worker (CHEW), community health workers (CHWs), clients and community members) in two purposively selected counties: Nairobi and Kitui. Qualitative data were digitally recorded, transcribed, translated and coded before framework analysis.Results: There is widespread community appreciation for the existing strategy. High attrition, lack of accountability for voluntary CHWs and lack of funds to pay CHW salaries, combined with high CHEW workload were seen as main drivers for strategy change. Areas for change identified include: lack of clear supervisory structure including provision of adequate travel resources, current uneven coverage and equity of community health services, limited community knowledge about the strategy revision and demand for home-based HIV testing and counselling.Conclusion: This in-depth analysis which captures multiple perspectives results in robust recommendations for strategy revision informed by the Five Wonders of Change Framework. These recommendations point towards a more people-centred health system for improved equity and effectiveness and indicate priority areas for action if success of policy change through the roll-out of the revised strategy is to be realized.

Challenges and prospects for implementation of community health volunteers’ digital health solutions in Kenya: a qualitative study

“…This also had an impact on the activities implemented. This observation is in agreement with existing reports that despite being clearly defined on paper and its growing role in delivering vital primary health care services, there is limited government support [18,19]. Several users expected extra financial motivation while others could not comfortably use the phones and desktop computers provided.…”

Navigating institutional complexity in the health sector: lessons from tobacco control in Kenya

“…Previously both health policy and implementation were coordinated from the central government at the ministry headquarters. The new constitution has devolved health functions-particularly implementation of tobacco control policies and regulations-to 47 newly created county governments, each with their own governor and assembly that also pass sub-national laws and regulations (Barkan and Mutua 2010;McCollum et al 2015). The fourth schedule of the constitution has decentralized some of the national government's functions to the county level with the national government responsible for health policy broadly, while the county governments are now responsible for the control of drugs, ensuring participation of local communities in governance at a local level, advertising and, importantly, promotion of primary health care.…”

Trust is the engine of change: A conceptual model for trust building in health systems

“…We describe work in progress in close to the community health systems in Kenya that provides initial theoretical validation. (58). Local elders, a facility nurse and the region's community health extension worker (paid staff), came together and participated in barasa, which in Swahili means "long sitting."…”