In this study, high‐temperature vulcanized silicone rubbers (HTV‐SRs) using fumed silica (FSi), precipitated silica (PSi), and modified precipitated silica (MPSi) as reinforcing fillers were prepared. The effect of morphology and surface chemistry of the silica on the thermal and mechanical properties of the resultant silicone rubbers was investigated using curing rheometer, scanning electron microscopy, mechanical test, and dynamic mechanical analysis. The thermo‐oxidative stability and solvent resistance of the vulcanized silicone rubbers were further evaluated via heat ageing test, extraction, and swelling experiments. It is shown that the mechanical properties (tensile modulus and tensile strength) of the as‐prepared HTV‐SRs are in the order of FSi > PSi > MPSi, which could be attributed to the molecular interaction between the filler and the matrix. FSi has the highest surface area, which enhances the hydrogen bonding interaction between the filler and the silicone matrix; while MPSi, in which part of SiOH groups have been consumed during modification, shows the weakest interaction among the three. The filler–matrix interaction could also explain the lowest swelling and sol fraction in FSi‐filled HTV‐SR, and the low viscosity and good processibility of PSi‐ and MPSi‐filled HTV‐SR. Furthermore, it is also shown that the MPSi‐filled HTV‐SR exhibits the highest retention of mechanical properties after thermal aging at 250 °C for 24 h, which could be attributed to the lowest acidity of the fillers. The possible mechanism for acid catalyzed hydrolytic chain scission and intramolecular chain backbiting has been proposed. © 2018 Wiley Periodicals, Inc. J. Appl. Polym. Sci. 2018, 135, 46646.